Florida’s new surgeon general skeptical of vaccines, opposes masks

Aurich

Director of Many Things
41,241
Ars Staff
Just a reminder, GameOvR is the same dipshit who claims to drive by 2 empty ERs in Wichita daily. Still hasn't provided proof.
Dives by empty ERs in Wichita, in Jacksonville, and was with a friend in California when she died if the vaccine, eh? Dude gets around i guess.
The person they listed is real, I looked.

https://www.dignitymemorial.com/obituar ... t-10322665

Nanci passed away suddenly on August 12, 2021 in Upland, CA due to complications from COVID (even though she was fully vaccinated) and pre-existing medical conditions.
Not my job to say if they knew her or not. I'm not linking her obituary out of any kind of spite, just worth noting the cause of death.

Let's keep the hyperbole out of this, and stick to the facts. I have no tolerance for vaccine misinformation here.
 
Upvote
13 (13 / 0)

Lt_Storm

Ars Tribunus Angusticlavius
20,224
Subscriptor++
Edit: though, given Social Security and Medicare, I suppose you could argue that it's zombie corpse is still shambling about.
Since both programs keep me and my wife alive, that 'zombie corpse shambling about' is fine with me. Unless you wish to return to the topic at hand, we're done sharing here.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not complaining that the zombie is still around. The complaint is about how someone decided to murder the new deal leaving us in a world mostly without labor unions and other good policies from that period.

You know, the entire plutocratic political philosophy which Ron Desantis advocates for and which lead to this particular asshole becoming Florida's Surgeon General; the one that rejects responsibility as being 'socialist' and which got socialism brought up in this conversation.
 
Upvote
7 (7 / 0)
Post content hidden for low score. Show…

numerobis

Ars Tribunus Angusticlavius
50,868
Subscriptor
How the fuck does someone like this earn a medical degree? It's like Boeing hiring a Chief Engineer that doesn't believe in the principles of aerodynamics....oh, wait, maybe that explains it all.

What do you call someone who graduated medical school at the bottom of their class?

Doctor.
Ideally, you don't call him a professor at a UC medical school.

C'mon, UCLA, you're dragging down the whole UC system hiring a guy like this. I shouldn't tease though. I have a vague memory of a Berkeley professor being about this far in denial. Maybe he was arguing that he'd invented a perpetual motion machine, or denying that global warming is a thing, I don't really remember, but every good school occasionally hires a loon.

Berkeley has the famous John Choon Yoo who wrote the torture memos for Bush. Wikipedia says he's the Emanuel S. Heller Professor of Law at the University of California, Berkeley, School of Law. Empathy isn't taught in law school.

Edit - possessives vs plural, again
I hope someday he gets waterboarded. And then made to stand crooked in a tiny cage while music is blasting.
 
Upvote
4 (4 / 0)

numerobis

Ars Tribunus Angusticlavius
50,868
Subscriptor
Just a reminder, GameOvR is the same dipshit who claims to drive by 2 empty ERs in Wichita daily. Still hasn't provided proof.
Dives by empty ERs in Wichita, in Jacksonville, and was with a friend in California when she died if the vaccine, eh? Dude gets around i guess.
The person they listed is real, I looked.

https://www.dignitymemorial.com/obituar ... t-10322665

Nanci passed away suddenly on August 12, 2021 in Upland, CA due to complications from COVID (even though she was fully vaccinated) and pre-existing medical conditions.
Not my job to say if they knew her or not. I'm not linking her obituary out of any kind of spite, just worth noting the cause of death.

Let's keep the hyperbole out of this, and stick to the facts. I have no tolerance for vaccine misinformation here.
The claim was I've witnessed one person die from getting the J&J vaccine.

So this is clearly the wrong Nanci in Upland CA.

That, or maybe something is a bit suspicious about the poster who claims to be routinely driving by ERs in Jacksonville and Wichita and happened to be chilling with a friend in CA who is one of the 88 people in the US who died after taking this particular vaccine.
 
Upvote
17 (17 / 0)

Basil Forthrightly

Ars Tribunus Angusticlavius
8,417
Subscriptor
ComfortablyNeurotic said:

You have some weird sexual issues with your mom if that’s the first thing you think of when you see a mask. I’m pretty sure that’s not legal where you live.

It may be legal if a close relative however... don't know the state.

Clearly it can be legal in New York since Giuliani literally married his cousin.

Normally you think of it being more of a deep south sort of thing, since the Europeans who settled that region initially were the ones who got tired of the European powers telling them they can't keep on with their blood feuds with other families. There was literally a tradition of rolling the betrothed up in a rug before the wedding down that way and some other fucked up things by almost anyone's standards then or now.

Side note, but it's kind of fascinating how, even over 200 years later, the unique cultures of the European groups that settled the three major regions of the Americas (New England, Tidewater/Mid-Atlantic, and South) still tends to influence the culture of those areas, and by understanding what motivated those groups can help you make sense of what goes on today.
The British accepted marriage between cousins after the Reformation. Interestingly it was very common amongst Quakers in the 18th and 19th centuries because of the rule until the middle of the 19th century against marrying outside the sect. Even in families that had left the tendency remained - Charles and Emma Darwin were cousins. It also suited all classes, from small rural communities to the aristocracy who sought to strengthen family allegiances.

I have Quaker ancestry of one great-great-grandparent and all of her known ancestors between 1650ish and 1840ish were Quakers.

That includes 2 pairs of first cousins who married and whose offspring married, as well as another first cousin pair and a lot of more distant cousins. Iirc, my most repeated ancestor had 6 different paths to my ancestress; though he wasn’t a Quaker, the bulk of his grandchildren in big families were.
 
Upvote
1 (1 / 0)

Faceless Man

Ars Legatus Legionis
11,646
Subscriptor++
By that logic I suppose that it is safe to take up smoking.

That's what the celery in a Bloody Mary is for. Veggies are magical health shields. The difference between Jimi Hendrix and Keith Richards is Keith Richards ate some broccoli one time, true story.
Actually, like Hendrix, Keith Richards ODed at the age of 27. It's just that the drugs haven't worn off yet, but when they do...


Keith Richards will become more powerful than we can possibly imagine?
No, but if he did start glowing blue, I don't think anyone would be in the least bit surprised.
 
Upvote
3 (3 / 0)

Faceless Man

Ars Legatus Legionis
11,646
Subscriptor++
I'm absolutely OK with FL and TX seceding from the rest of us, and just letting them spiral down to their inevitable conclusion. Sorry (not sorry).

Make sure we keep the subs and Nukes.

So that is why Australia is getting US nuclear powered submarines…
We don't want them. It's just certain members of the cabinet, desperate for a distraction from mishandling of the pandemic, corruption, sex scandals, and general incompetence.

The main achievement of the AUKUS deal so far is to push back when we can expect our first new submarines to arrive, and piss off the French with whom we had just earlier this year confirmed the existing deal for French conventional submarines.
 
Upvote
6 (7 / -1)
I'm absolutely OK with FL and TX seceding from the rest of us, and just letting them spiral down to their inevitable conclusion. Sorry (not sorry).

Make sure we keep the subs and Nukes.

So that is why Australia is getting US nuclear powered submarines…
We don't want them. It's just certain members of the cabinet, desperate for a distraction from mishandling of the pandemic, corruption, sex scandals, and general incompetence.

The main achievement of the AUKUS deal so far is to push back when we can expect our first new submarines to arrive, and piss off the French with whom we had just earlier this year confirmed the existing deal for French conventional submarines.

But how else is Smoko from Marketing expected to quietly get back and forth from Hawaii whilst Australia has its year long bushfire season?

The acting beetroot PM is all for supporting the Federal Attorney General who took a million dollar bribe from foreign powers - which has to be the assumption until he declares who is behind the blind trust - so he could sue the public broadcaster about rape allegations. Allegations that didn’t name him, but he was the only one who put up his hand to say it was himself.

It’s not like they can even blame the previous government for the problems with the French Submarine deal. The Liberal-National coalition parties have been in power since 2013 and the deal was made in 2016. But I’m sure it was Labour’s fault.
 
Upvote
5 (5 / 0)

RoninX

Ars Praefectus
3,245
Subscriptor
DeSantis has already killed more people with Covid than his margin of victory in his 2018 election to office. You can bet that 90% of those deaths are people who voted for him.

Looks like Florida will get a Democrat governor next year.

There is already a conspiracy theory doing their rounds on the right wing media that Democrats are goading Republicans into not taking the vaccine so that they die off quicker and win the election.

https://www.breitbart.com/entertainment ... ters-dead/

The people of Florida not only voted for a GOP governor but also a GOP majority in both houses in their state - it is difficult to feel sorry for a population who have signed their own death warrant (I do however feel for those who get out and vote against the GOP, see sanity of their state slip away but lack the funds/means to be move out of the state).
Towards the beginning of the Trump administration, I snarkily posted in a different forum that Trump supporters should do a GoFundMe if they wanted their stupid wall. A few days later I read a report about Build The Wall Awhile ago in this forum I recall making a snarky comment about how maybe a conspiracy theory could be started about "leftists" fomenting vaccine resistance in Trump supporters in order to change the country's demographics. Now you post that Breitbart link. Damn. Snarky comments aren't supposed to be actual action plans.

So does this mean that Trump supporters will start getting vaccinated to "own the libs", and that a Breitbart conspiracy theory will... save a lot of lives?
 
Upvote
3 (3 / 0)

Faceless Man

Ars Legatus Legionis
11,646
Subscriptor++
I'm absolutely OK with FL and TX seceding from the rest of us, and just letting them spiral down to their inevitable conclusion. Sorry (not sorry).

Make sure we keep the subs and Nukes.

So that is why Australia is getting US nuclear powered submarines…
We don't want them. It's just certain members of the cabinet, desperate for a distraction from mishandling of the pandemic, corruption, sex scandals, and general incompetence.

The main achievement of the AUKUS deal so far is to push back when we can expect our first new submarines to arrive, and piss off the French with whom we had just earlier this year confirmed the existing deal for French conventional submarines.

But how else is Smoko from Marketing expected to quietly get back and forth from Hawaii whilst Australia has its year long bushfire season?

The acting beetroot PM is all for supporting the Federal Attorney General who took a million dollar bribe from foreign powers - which has to be the assumption until he declares who is behind the blind trust - so he could sue the public broadcaster about rape allegations. Allegations that didn’t name him, but he was the only one who put up his hand to say it was himself.

It’s not like they can even blame the previous government for the problems with the French Submarine deal. The Liberal-National coalition parties have been in power since 2013 and the deal was made in 2016. But I’m sure it was Labour’s fault.
Well, it was Malcolm Turnbull, so near enough to the ALP.

Besides, I don't know if the Failed Marketing Executive-in-Chief would want to travel in a submarine. He seems perfectly happy to fly around in planes, after getting special permission to do so. After all, who knew he was in the US this week?
 
Upvote
3 (3 / 0)
D

Deleted member 388703

Guest
In case you needed a reminder, here it is. The WSJ is the rich man’s Fox News.

It also needs to be sued out of existence — forced to support all the covid19 orphans and send them to Harvard. Forced to reimburse the feds for medical expenses of the unvaccinated. Etc. If Gawker can be put out of business merely for outing an anti-LGBT gay man surely society has better reasons to shut down Rupert Murdoch’s propaganda empire.

Doesn't appear you have much confidence in your beliefs when you're always trying to shut down the 1st amendment rights of others. Ironically, it seems to be a common theme among the people so quick to claim conservatives are fascists.
[Projects facts not in evidence]
 
Upvote
7 (7 / 0)
D

Deleted member 388703

Guest
Just a reminder, GameOvR is the same dipshit who claims to drive by 2 empty ERs in Wichita daily. Still hasn't provided proof.
Dives by empty ERs in Wichita, in Jacksonville, and was with a friend in California when she died if the vaccine, eh? Dude gets around i guess.
The person they listed is real, I looked.

https://www.dignitymemorial.com/obituar ... t-10322665

Nanci passed away suddenly on August 12, 2021 in Upland, CA due to complications from COVID (even though she was fully vaccinated) and pre-existing medical conditions.
Not my job to say if they knew her or not. I'm not linking her obituary out of any kind of spite, just worth noting the cause of death.

Let's keep the hyperbole out of this, and stick to the facts. I have no tolerance for vaccine misinformation here.
The claim was I've witnessed one person die from getting the J&J vaccine.

So this is clearly the wrong Nanci in Upland CA.

That, or maybe something is a bit suspicious about the poster who claims to be routinely driving by ERs in Jacksonville and Wichita and happened to be chilling with a friend in CA who is one of the 88 people in the US who died after taking this particular vaccine.
It's quite a BuckyJoe/thr2rmrf lifestyle he leads.
 
Upvote
7 (7 / 0)
Typical clickbait article for the usual crowd here. Hope you’re all enjoying the echo chamber. You’re sooo much better than all those morons in Florida.

Do you know how many smack-fu grasshoppers we get in here, each with their own version of reality and their quavery-voiced, self-righteous entreaties to “consider alternative opinions”? More than the generally rational tone of this place would lead one to believe.

Do you know how many of those people actually sound credible enough to change minds? None that I’ve seen.

And do you know how we typically react to those types? Chuckle, down-arrow, and move on.

You see, it’s not the echo chamber I enjoy. It’s the very brief, fleeting sense of satisfaction from punching that down-arrow and knowing that while I have little control over the state of the nation, I have at least made some small amount of progress towards shutting someone like you up.

I think you may want to reconsider your presence here. I don’t see how anything you have to say will amount to anything more than a waste of your time.

Personally, I think those who refuse the vaccine are making a poor medical choice. However, I do appreciate the concepts of individual responsibility and states' rights. I think many attitudes like yours expressed in these forum comments lead to even harder lines being drawn by those making the poor health decision. In their minds, it's now turned into a freedom/personal liberty stand. I can hardly blame them.
I can. I can blame them thusly: They don't live by themselves alone in a bubble. Their 'personal liberty' ends when they live with everyone else, breathe on everyone else, cough on everyone else. IF they live in this nation, and wave the flag of this nation and yell USA! USA! USA! that means they FUCKING LIVE with OTHER AMERICANS who deserve to have a chance at living with others who fucking take responsibility of living in that society.
MOST People don't drive 40MPH through red lights. MOST people don't touch pieces of metal that a sign warns them DO NOT TOUCH 40,000 FUCKING VOLTS.
MOST people don't drive 100 fucking miles an hour up hairpin turns on a mountain side.
You know why? Because people who do that are called 'Assholes'. You know what else we call them?
'Dead Assholes'.
So, you can hardly blame them? Well, come to think of it, let 'em have their 'freedom/personal liberty stand'. They can have it all day long until they fucking croak.
Who gives a shit?
 
Upvote
13 (13 / 0)

CraigJ ✅

Ars Legatus Legionis
27,010
Subscriptor
Meanwhile, in Vermont, the Delta wave is barely a ripple. They sure must eat their vegetables there!
It's well known maple syrup offers protection from many kinds of virus.

Though the key is to snort the syrup, after swallowing a zinc supplement. It does no good if you swallow it.

I heard that Starbucks Pumpkin Spice syrup protects you from COVID, bit you need to administer it rectally.
 
Upvote
6 (6 / 0)

Lt_Storm

Ars Tribunus Angusticlavius
20,224
Subscriptor++
"To date, there have been more than 42 million cases of COVID-19 in the US and more than 676,000 people have died. The COVID-19 pandemic is now the deadliest disease event in US history, exceeding the estimated 675,000 US deaths during the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic."

I cannot believe NO ONE on here commented to this from what I could see. This is literally just flat out WRONG thing to say. By the same argument for all the racial injustice posts on here by statistics then there is nothing wrong with anything in this country and white people are experiencing the most suppression.......... since we apparently don't care about percentages and just care about numbers............
THERE WERE NOT 330 million americans in 1918...... MAKING IT NOT THE DEADLIEST DISEASE IN US HISTORY SINCE THERE WAS ONLY somewhere between 92-106 million americans. Unreal you just post this type of stuff with no thought of math. By percentage this doesn't even come close. This site is becoming more and more a joke when it comes to accuracy of math among other things. Absolutely sickening.

So, this comparison doesn't work. After all, 1918 was before the invention of most of modern medicine. As a result, you are comparing apples to oranges. The reality is that, back in 1918, we didn't have intubation, we didn't even have oxygen treatment, and we certainly didn't have miracle drugs. As a result of this difference in ability to treat, Covid would have been many times more deadly. So given the scales of these unknowns, comparing the numbers directly is surprisingly reasonable. Modern medicine has reduced the probability of death from such diseases by an order of magnitude, one probably larger than the population differences.
 
Upvote
18 (18 / 0)

Wheels Of Confusion

Ars Legatus Legionis
75,746
Subscriptor
Meanwhile, in Vermont, the Delta wave is barely a ripple. They sure must eat their vegetables there!
It's well known maple syrup offers protection from many kinds of virus.

Though the key is to snort the syrup, after swallowing a zinc supplement. It does no good if you swallow it.

I heard that Starbucks Pumpkin Spice syrup protects you from COVID, bit you need to administer it rectally.
Please don't spread this useless, irresponsible disinformation.


Tell them "Hey, did you hear? They're putting vaccine in cattle! Giving the shots to the cows, man! You want to get that in your beef?"

Watch as a big chunk of America slims down and does something good for the environment at the same time. If you're gonna lie, at least do it for a good cause or two.

Make sure not to intimate that this is routine livestock vaccination. Let them think it's THE Vaccine(s).
 
Upvote
10 (10 / 0)
Post content hidden for low score. Show…

Ozy

Ars Tribunus Angusticlavius
7,450
From the article:
"The state should be promoting good health, and vaccination isn't the only path to that," Ladapo said. "It's been treated almost like a religion, and that's just senseless. There's a lot of good pathways to health, and vaccination is not the only one. So, we support measures for good health—that's vaccination, losing weight, it's exercising more, it's eating more fruits and vegetables, everything. We support it all."

To be clear, while losing weight, exercising, and eating fruits and vegetables are generally good for health, they will not prevent SARS-CoV-2 infection or transmission.

Given how transmissible Delta is, neither does the vaccine. A 90% reduction in the likelihood of infection doesn't matter much if you integrate the risk over the next 5 years. So you avoid COVID in 2021 and you'll get it in 2022 or 2023

And if you're vaccinated you stand a good chance of avoiding the ICU and a tube shoved down your throat.
 
Upvote
15 (15 / 0)
"To date, there have been more than 42 million cases of COVID-19 in the US and more than 676,000 people have died. The COVID-19 pandemic is now the deadliest disease event in US history, exceeding the estimated 675,000 US deaths during the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic."

I cannot believe NO ONE on here commented to this from what I could see. This is literally just flat out WRONG thing to say. By the same argument for all the racial injustice posts on here by statistics then there is nothing wrong with anything in this country and white people are experiencing the most suppression.......... since we apparently don't care about percentages and just care about numbers............
THERE WERE NOT 330 million americans in 1918...... MAKING IT NOT THE DEADLIEST DISEASE IN US HISTORY SINCE THERE WAS ONLY somewhere between 92-106 million americans. Unreal you just post this type of stuff with no thought of math. By percentage this doesn't even come close. This site is becoming more and more a joke when it comes to accuracy of math among other things. Absolutely sickening.

So, this comparison doesn't work. After all, 1918 was before the invention of most of modern medicine. As a result, you are comparing apples to oranges. The reality is that, back in 1918, we didn't have intubation, we didn't even have oxygen treatment, and we certainly didn't have miracle drugs. As a result of this difference in ability to treat, Covid would have been many times more deadly. So given the scales of these unknowns, comparing the numbers directly is surprisingly reasonable. Modern medicine has reduced the probability of death from such diseases by an order of magnitude, one probably larger than the population differences.
Pro Tip: Don't reply to morons. It wastes everyone's time and encourages the moron.
 
Upvote
9 (10 / -1)

numerobis

Ars Tribunus Angusticlavius
50,868
Subscriptor
Meanwhile, in Vermont, the Delta wave is barely a ripple. They sure must eat their vegetables there!
It's well known maple syrup offers protection from many kinds of virus.

Though the key is to snort the syrup, after swallowing a zinc supplement. It does no good if you swallow it.
Apparently these guys export to France and UK:
https://www.maple-flavour.com/Whiskey-a ... -6_20.html
Probably you can find another distributor in the US?

There's enough alcohol in there to bring the syrup intranasally through the back of the throat. Plus, as shown above, ethanol is also protective per oral. So this offers double protection.
 
Upvote
4 (4 / 0)

CraigJ ✅

Ars Legatus Legionis
27,010
Subscriptor
From the article:
"The state should be promoting good health, and vaccination isn't the only path to that," Ladapo said. "It's been treated almost like a religion, and that's just senseless. There's a lot of good pathways to health, and vaccination is not the only one. So, we support measures for good health—that's vaccination, losing weight, it's exercising more, it's eating more fruits and vegetables, everything. We support it all."

To be clear, while losing weight, exercising, and eating fruits and vegetables are generally good for health, they will not prevent SARS-CoV-2 infection or transmission.

Given how transmissible Delta is, neither does the vaccine. A 90% reduction in the likelihood of infection doesn't matter much if you integrate the risk over the next 5 years. So you avoid COVID in 2021 and you'll get it in 2022 or 2023

And if you're vaccinated you stand a good chance of avoiding the ICU and a tube shoved down your throat.

Unless you're in a car accident, have a stroke or a heart attack, etc. Then you get to die in the ambulance because all the ICU beds are full of plague rats.
 
Upvote
17 (17 / 0)
From the article:
"The state should be promoting good health, and vaccination isn't the only path to that," Ladapo said. "It's been treated almost like a religion, and that's just senseless. There's a lot of good pathways to health, and vaccination is not the only one. So, we support measures for good health—that's vaccination, losing weight, it's exercising more, it's eating more fruits and vegetables, everything. We support it all."

To be clear, while losing weight, exercising, and eating fruits and vegetables are generally good for health, they will not prevent SARS-CoV-2 infection or transmission.

Given how transmissible Delta is, neither does the vaccine. A 90% reduction in the likelihood of infection doesn't matter much if you integrate the risk over the next 5 years. So you avoid COVID in 2021 and you'll get it in 2022 or 2023

And if you're vaccinated you stand a good chance of avoiding the ICU and a tube shoved down your throat.

Unless you're in a car accident, have a stroke or a heart attack, etc. Then you get to die in the ambulance because all the ICU beds are full of plague rats.

And the 'sensible middle ground' is not engaging the one outside the middle ground.
 
Upvote
4 (4 / 0)
From the article:
"The state should be promoting good health, and vaccination isn't the only path to that," Ladapo said. "It's been treated almost like a religion, and that's just senseless. There's a lot of good pathways to health, and vaccination is not the only one. So, we support measures for good health—that's vaccination, losing weight, it's exercising more, it's eating more fruits and vegetables, everything. We support it all."

To be clear, while losing weight, exercising, and eating fruits and vegetables are generally good for health, they will not prevent SARS-CoV-2 infection or transmission.

Given how transmissible Delta is, neither does the vaccine. A 90% reduction in the likelihood of infection doesn't matter much if you integrate the risk over the next 5 years. So you avoid COVID in 2021 and you'll get it in 2022 or 2023 if you forgo travel and take a series of other precautions. The reality is that even those of us who are fully vaccinated will eventually get infected -- and for almost all of us, it'll be so mild that we'll barely notice.

In that light, it's absolutely worth talking about tradeoffs. If wearing masks were entirely costless, why didn't the attendees of the Met Gala wear them? Why didn't the SF mayor when she went to a packed club (even though a mask mandate was in effect)? Evidently, it's not completely costless. More importantly, if people don't go to the gym because working out with a mask is really annoying, then we have to balance the costs from worse cardiovascular health with the reduction in COVID exposure.

We're just largely incapable to have conversations around tradeoffs. So places like SF have mask mandates even in places where everyone needs to be vaccinated. And places like Florida prohibit mask mandates even in places where they make sense. Because polarization means we need to occupy the extremes of possible responses, rather than look for a sensible middle ground.

From the Idaho thread:
“ Of the patients hospitalized with COVID-19, 90 percent are unvaccinated, as are 98 percent of ICU patients.”

That is a state which is almost 50/50 vaccinated/unvaccinated (41% fully vaccinated).

So roughly fifty times more likely ending up in the ICU. Now the more people who vaccinate the less total amount of cases and of those less and less extreme outcomes. So it isn’t a simple case of saying a 90% reduction in risk for the individual when exposed, you have to include how many are vaccinated overall to figure out the chance of exposure too.
 
Upvote
12 (12 / 0)
From the article:
"The state should be promoting good health, and vaccination isn't the only path to that," Ladapo said. "It's been treated almost like a religion, and that's just senseless. There's a lot of good pathways to health, and vaccination is not the only one. So, we support measures for good health—that's vaccination, losing weight, it's exercising more, it's eating more fruits and vegetables, everything. We support it all."

To be clear, while losing weight, exercising, and eating fruits and vegetables are generally good for health, they will not prevent SARS-CoV-2 infection or transmission.

Given how transmissible Delta is, neither does the vaccine. A 90% reduction in the likelihood of infection doesn't matter much if you integrate the risk over the next 5 years. So you avoid COVID in 2021 and you'll get it in 2022 or 2023 if you forgo travel and take a series of other precautions. The reality is that even those of us who are fully vaccinated will eventually get infected -- and for almost all of us, it'll be so mild that we'll barely notice.

In that light, it's absolutely worth talking about tradeoffs. If wearing masks were entirely costless, why didn't the attendees of the Met Gala wear them? Why didn't the SF mayor when she went to a packed club (even though a mask mandate was in effect)? Evidently, it's not completely costless. More importantly, if people don't go to the gym because working out with a mask is really annoying, then we have to balance the costs from worse cardiovascular health with the reduction in COVID exposure.

We're just largely incapable to have conversations around tradeoffs. So places like SF have mask mandates even in places where everyone needs to be vaccinated. And places like Florida prohibit mask mandates even in places where they make sense. Because polarization means we need to occupy the extremes of possible responses, rather than look for a sensible middle ground.

From the Idaho thread:
“ Of the patients hospitalized with COVID-19, 90 percent are unvaccinated, as are 98 percent of ICU patients.”

That is a state which is almost 50/50 vaccinated/unvaccinated (41% fully vaccinated).

So roughly fifty times more likely ending up in the ICU. Now the more people who vaccinate the less total amount of cases and of those less and less extreme outcomes. So it isn’t a simple case of saying a 90% reduction in risk for the individual when exposed, you have to include how many are vaccinated overall to figure out the chance of exposure too.
Ah now you've done it. You gave the 'sensible middle ground' to the one who couldn't give two shits about any middle ground, sensible or otherwise.
 
Upvote
7 (7 / 0)

graylshaped

Ars Legatus Legionis
68,206
Subscriptor++
How the fuck does someone like this earn a medical degree? It's like Boeing hiring a Chief Engineer that doesn't believe in the principles of aerodynamics....oh, wait, maybe that explains it all.

What do you call someone who graduated medical school at the bottom of their class?

Doctor.
Ideally, you don't call him a professor at a UC medical school.

C'mon, UCLA, you're dragging down the whole UC system hiring a guy like this. I shouldn't tease though. I have a vague memory of a Berkeley professor being about this far in denial. Maybe he was arguing that he'd invented a perpetual motion machine, or denying that global warming is a thing, I don't really remember, but every good school occasionally hires a loon.

Many schools hire someone with a bee in their bonnet, and after years of failing to prove it, that prof gets ornery and cantankerous and no one likes their class, and no grad student really wants to work with them, but by then they have tenure. There is always a company out there willing to pay offer grants to someone to do research that will be to the company's liking. A political party wishing to push an agenda over truth has a keen nose for such doctors.

Also for certain types of lawyers, but getting into that would be off topic.
 
Upvote
7 (7 / 0)

graylshaped

Ars Legatus Legionis
68,206
Subscriptor++
From the article:
"The state should be promoting good health, and vaccination isn't the only path to that," Ladapo said. "It's been treated almost like a religion, and that's just senseless. There's a lot of good pathways to health, and vaccination is not the only one. So, we support measures for good health—that's vaccination, losing weight, it's exercising more, it's eating more fruits and vegetables, everything. We support it all."

To be clear, while losing weight, exercising, and eating fruits and vegetables are generally good for health, they will not prevent SARS-CoV-2 infection or transmission.

Given how transmissible Delta is, neither does the vaccine. A 90% reduction in the likelihood of infection doesn't matter much if you integrate the risk over the next 5 years. So you avoid COVID in 2021 and you'll get it in 2022 or 2023

And if you're vaccinated you stand a good chance of avoiding the ICU and a tube shoved down your throat.

Unless you're in a car accident, have a stroke or a heart attack, etc. Then you get to die in the ambulance because all the ICU beds are full of plague rats.

Funny how all the apologists seem to miss that downstream consequence...
 
Upvote
14 (14 / 0)

Bernardo Verda

Ars Legatus Legionis
13,145
Subscriptor++
Just a reminder, GameOvR is the same dipshit who claims to drive by 2 empty ERs in Wichita daily. Still hasn't provided proof.
Dives by empty ERs in Wichita, in Jacksonville, and was with a friend in California when she died if the vaccine, eh? Dude gets around i guess.
The person they listed is real, I looked.

https://www.dignitymemorial.com/obituar ... t-10322665

Nanci passed away suddenly on August 12, 2021 in Upland, CA due to complications from COVID (even though she was fully vaccinated) and pre-existing medical conditions.
Not my job to say if they knew her or not. I'm not linking her obituary out of any kind of spite, just worth noting the cause of death.

Let's keep the hyperbole out of this, and stick to the facts. I have no tolerance for vaccine misinformation here.

So, contrary to his claim, she died from the actual Covid virus, and not from the vaccine (iirc, he even named the particular vaccine).

That seems like a pretty basic mistake to make about how one's own friend died, doesn't it? Especially for someone with an actual, specific interest in the subject.

I'm not finding this guy to be at all credible.
 
Upvote
17 (17 / 0)
From the article:
"The state should be promoting good health, and vaccination isn't the only path to that," Ladapo said. "It's been treated almost like a religion, and that's just senseless. There's a lot of good pathways to health, and vaccination is not the only one. So, we support measures for good health—that's vaccination, losing weight, it's exercising more, it's eating more fruits and vegetables, everything. We support it all."

To be clear, while losing weight, exercising, and eating fruits and vegetables are generally good for health, they will not prevent SARS-CoV-2 infection or transmission.

Given how transmissible Delta is, neither does the vaccine. A 90% reduction in the likelihood of infection doesn't matter much if you integrate the risk over the next 5 years. So you avoid COVID in 2021 and you'll get it in 2022 or 2023 if you forgo travel and take a series of other precautions. The reality is that even those of us who are fully vaccinated will eventually get infected -- and for almost all of us, it'll be so mild that we'll barely notice.

In that light, it's absolutely worth talking about tradeoffs. If wearing masks were entirely costless, why didn't the attendees of the Met Gala wear them? Why didn't the SF mayor when she went to a packed club (even though a mask mandate was in effect)? Evidently, it's not completely costless. More importantly, if people don't go to the gym because working out with a mask is really annoying, then we have to balance the costs from worse cardiovascular health with the reduction in COVID exposure.

We're just largely incapable to have conversations around tradeoffs. So places like SF have mask mandates even in places where everyone needs to be vaccinated. And places like Florida prohibit mask mandates even in places where they make sense. Because polarization means we need to occupy the extremes of possible responses, rather than look for a sensible middle ground.

From the Idaho thread:
“ Of the patients hospitalized with COVID-19, 90 percent are unvaccinated, as are 98 percent of ICU patients.”

That is a state which is almost 50/50 vaccinated/unvaccinated (41% fully vaccinated).

So roughly fifty times more likely ending up in the ICU. Now the more people who vaccinate the less total amount of cases and of those less and less extreme outcomes. So it isn’t a simple case of saying a 90% reduction in risk for the individual when exposed, you have to include how many are vaccinated overall to figure out the chance of exposure too.
Ah now you've done it. You gave the 'sensible middle ground' to the one who couldn't give two shits about any middle ground, sensible or otherwise.

Opposing arguments:
Get vaccinated when you get the opportunity,
Don’t get vaccinated if you have medical contraindications.

Hence the middle ground is if you cannot get the vaccine due to medical reasons encourage those who can, so they can protect both themselves and yourself.

Not part of the balanced argument:
Individuals whose choices harm themselves and others.

Adults are responsible for their choices including choosing propaganda over critical thinking.

Edit: clarification
 
Upvote
7 (7 / 0)

graylshaped

Ars Legatus Legionis
68,206
Subscriptor++
It happened today. My kid, in a school with mandatory masks indoors, was outside and a fellow student told him to take his mask off. "It's okay," my kid said.

"But we're outside and you don't need it."

"I'd rather wear it than get sick," said my six-year-old, and went to play with somebody else. Without scaring him or lecturing him, we told him we were glad he made the choice to stay safe, reinforced his decision to walk away--and made sure he knew if he felt bullied about it to talk to his teacher.
 
Upvote
17 (17 / 0)

balthazarr

Ars Tribunus Angusticlavius
6,905
Subscriptor++
I'm absolutely OK with FL and TX seceding from the rest of us, and just letting them spiral down to their inevitable conclusion. Sorry (not sorry).

Make sure we keep the subs and Nukes.

So that is why Australia is getting US nuclear powered submarines…
We don't want them. It's just certain members of the cabinet, desperate for a distraction from mishandling of the pandemic, corruption, sex scandals, and general incompetence.

The main achievement of the AUKUS deal so far is to push back when we can expect our first new submarines to arrive, and piss off the French with whom we had just earlier this year confirmed the existing deal for French conventional submarines.

It's much, much worse than that - Scomo and his buddies apparently reassured France about the subs deal the day of the AUKUS announcement - France has an absolute right to be pissed, the only real questions are how big a diplomatic spat will result, and for how long.

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-09-22/ ... /100481322
 
Upvote
9 (9 / 0)

Basil Forthrightly

Ars Tribunus Angusticlavius
8,417
Subscriptor
Meanwhile, in Vermont, the Delta wave is barely a ripple. They sure must eat their vegetables there!
It's well known maple syrup offers protection from many kinds of virus.

Though the key is to snort the syrup, after swallowing a zinc supplement. It does no good if you swallow it.
Apparently these guys export to France and UK:
https://www.maple-flavour.com/Whiskey-a ... -6_20.html
Probably you can find another distributor in the US?

There's enough alcohol in there to bring the syrup intranasally through the back of the throat. Plus, as shown above, ethanol is also protective per oral. So this offers double protection.

I’ll see your maple syrup whiskey and raise you lobster ice cream.

Though the website seems to have some bitrot, the store most definitely still has it as of this weekend.
 
Upvote
1 (1 / 0)
At least a third of them have boners for Armageddon. I just can't believe this shi!'s really happening.
The Republican Party is a death cult.

This isn't hyperbole or exaggeration. It is a slight simplification (technically it's a group of death cults, power cults, wealth cults, and cults of personality but the death cults are in control and acting with common purpose).
 
Upvote
6 (6 / 0)
Post content hidden for low score. Show…

Cognac

Ars Praefectus
5,399
Subscriptor++
This article is somewhat misleading. The sad state we are in is one where fear and half truths are portrayed as science. Science, the Vaccines are very effective at preventing hospitalization or death from covid. The data from highly vaccinated nations points to it not preventing the spread of the disease. The CDC has noted this by changing its wording from preventing spread to preventing hospitalization/death. Herd immunity from vaccination does not appear to have occurred anywhere in the world. We have to learn to live with covid.
How do we do that?
Get vaccinated.
Reduce Obesity, this is the single largest commorbity.

It is right for the doctor to stress that vaccination is not a silver bullet solution. That overall health and losing weight are very impactful to reducing your risk of dying from Covid.

This should not be partisan or controversial.

Strange place we are in where sound medical advise from a Surgeon General becomes political.

Your statement is, how to put it, misleading as fuuuuck.

Sure, it's true that obesity is the single largest comorbidity to covid-19 deaths. And?

It's also the single biggest comorbidity to just about Every. Other. Cause. Of. Death. Influenza. Cancer. Heart attacks. Gun violence. Dysentery. You name it. You died? Chances are you were fat (at least in most western countries, and certainly in the US).

Only in a few cases does being fat cause you to die of that thing. In the case of covid, it's a non-factor. It's like saying the car was white when describing the scene of a car accident. About 20% of vehicles involved in accidents are white. Are you also suggesting that banning white cars would reduce vehicle accidents by 20%? Because that's pretty much the equivalent of what you're suggesting. People aren't dying of covid because they're fat. They're dying of covid because they got covid.
 
Upvote
18 (18 / 0)
From the article:
"The state should be promoting good health, and vaccination isn't the only path to that," Ladapo said. "It's been treated almost like a religion, and that's just senseless. There's a lot of good pathways to health, and vaccination is not the only one. So, we support measures for good health—that's vaccination, losing weight, it's exercising more, it's eating more fruits and vegetables, everything. We support it all."

To be clear, while losing weight, exercising, and eating fruits and vegetables are generally good for health, they will not prevent SARS-CoV-2 infection or transmission.

Given how transmissible Delta is, neither does the vaccine. A 90% reduction in the likelihood of infection doesn't matter much if you integrate the risk over the next 5 years. So you avoid COVID in 2021 and you'll get it in 2022 or 2023 if you forgo travel and take a series of other precautions. The reality is that even those of us who are fully vaccinated will eventually get infected -- and for almost all of us, it'll be so mild that we'll barely notice.

In that light, it's absolutely worth talking about tradeoffs. If wearing masks were entirely costless, why didn't the attendees of the Met Gala wear them? Why didn't the SF mayor when she went to a packed club (even though a mask mandate was in effect)? Evidently, it's not completely costless. More importantly, if people don't go to the gym because working out with a mask is really annoying, then we have to balance the costs from worse cardiovascular health with the reduction in COVID exposure.

We're just largely incapable to have conversations around tradeoffs. So places like SF have mask mandates even in places where everyone needs to be vaccinated. And places like Florida prohibit mask mandates even in places where they make sense. Because polarization means we need to occupy the extremes of possible responses, rather than look for a sensible middle ground.

From the Idaho thread:
“ Of the patients hospitalized with COVID-19, 90 percent are unvaccinated, as are 98 percent of ICU patients.”

That is a state which is almost 50/50 vaccinated/unvaccinated (41% fully vaccinated).

So roughly fifty times more likely ending up in the ICU. Now the more people who vaccinate the less total amount of cases and of those less and less extreme outcomes. So it isn’t a simple case of saying a 90% reduction in risk for the individual when exposed, you have to include how many are vaccinated overall to figure out the chance of exposure too.
Of course, vaccines work and vaccinated people are much less likely to be hospitalized. But there are two different objectives and both your response and the Ars article conflate them:

(1) reduce transmission, prevent more cases
(2) reduce the severity of cases, prevent hospitalizations/deaths

Vaccines clearly help with (2), but they're unlikely to prevent someone from getting infected in the long run. So as an individual who is vaccinated, it's very likely not worth passing on activities to avoid infection: it's just delaying the inevitable. For a public health official to say this is just being upfront with people. You'll hear the same in much of Europe, the UK, or Israel. Herd immunity and containment are out of the picture.

Florida's surgeon general saying that we should also invest in other ways to improve people's health is consistent with objective (2). The Ars article highlighting that this doesn't prevent infection is needlessly snarky: that's not the claim, nor is it the objective for anyone who is being upfront about what can be achieved.

As for the role of obesity: https://www.nih.gov/news-events/nih-res ... conditions
The researchers estimated that more than 900,000 COVID-19 hospitalizations occurred through November 2020. Based on their model, 30% of these hospitalizations were attributable to obesity, 26% to hypertension, 21% to diabetes, and 12% to heart failure. These people would still have been infected with COVID-19, but likely would not have been sick enough to need hospitalization.

More than one of these conditions are often present in the same person. The model also estimated hospitalizations due to different combinations. The numbers weren’t simply additive. In total, 64% of the hospitalizations might have been prevented if not for the four conditions.

If we didn't have an obesity epidemic, we'd have had many fewer deaths and hospitals would not be under the strain they are. Seems like something that should be mentioned, no?
That is precisely the logic that supports universal vaccination. But that isn't why Ladapo was appointed. Since you mention the UK, this is the plan for the coming months. Get vaccinated if you aren't already, a booster if offered, a flu innoculation as well, take precautions against infection and expect further controls if things get much worse.

Because if we cannot eradicate the virus, we have to minimise the chances of becoming seriously ill as a result, reduce the pressure on health services which will be kept busy as a result of the pandemic, and reduce viral loads so that we have a chance to build immunity over time. Maintaining a healthy weight and taking exercise are not inconsistent with that, far from it, but they are hardly central.

If Lapado can persuade De Santos of the good sense of all that and convey the message clearly to Florida's residents well and good. But do you suggest that the governor would have made the appointment if Lapado had said that at interview?
 
Upvote
19 (19 / 0)