ChatGPT can now write erotica as OpenAI eases up on AI paternalism

bodrius

Wise, Aged Ars Veteran
154
I'm not sure looks matter too much when it comes to text-generating models.

Wait, that gave me a thought. Is there such a thing as an uncanny valley in writing, or is it all "just bad"?
Our main hope for literature to remain a creative human endeavor is that there is an uncanny valley in writing. For now. The longer the text the more that it shows.

Its not that AI writing is just bad, with modern models and fine-tuning its not even "human-levels of bad" but there are still some patterns that read AI-generated.

Similar to how some corporate-speak always reads as corporate-speak (you can visualize the meeting doing this by committee, but it may be created by an individual self-editorializing to feel the same)
 
Upvote
7 (7 / 0)

MJMullinII

Ars Scholae Palatinae
991
Subscriptor
Expect lots of SCSI disks, hot swaps, and 3.5 inch floppies?
Question: in the modern era, is there really that much difference between SATA and SAS disks for bulk storage anymore? I remember SCSI always claimed the mantle of "more reliable" but I've seen so many bulk storage servers using cheaper SATA disks and wonder if it's worth doing SAS for a home server?
 
Upvote
1 (3 / -2)

ChatGPT can now write erotica as OpenAI eases up on AI paternalism​

Aside from restricting the creation of pornography, paternalism in AI can get in the way of professionals using ChatGPT for analysis of crime scene descriptions by law enforcement, certain types of news stories, legal documents that may include violence or sexual content, and sometimes medical texts.
Under sensitive content, ChatGPT's guidelines mirror what we stated above: Erotica or gore may only be generated under specific circumstances that include educational, medical, and historical contexts or when transforming user-provided content.
I'm not sure that the above use case is much helped by the addition of barely-restrained horniness:

"ChatGPT, please summarise this police statement."

- "The person being interrogated flushed, lips slightly parted as the officer began his questioning..."

"Oh, goddamnit."
 
Upvote
6 (6 / 0)

Marlor_AU

Ars Tribunus Angusticlavius
7,670
Subscriptor
If it's anything like generative imagery, it's going to get interesting.

"Joan held his hand, feeling his fingers enmeshed in hers, those seven digits caressing her hand gently. Without warning, he picked her up and threw her on the bed, face down, nuzzling the back of her neck, kissing the parted lips that lie there. He then climbed upon her, one leg to her left, one to her right, and the other braced against the headboard."
 
Last edited:
Upvote
33 (33 / 0)

Purpleivan

Ars Praetorian
419
Subscriptor++
I’ve just had ChatGPT rewrite the chestburster scene from Alien as sensual gore and as children’s television. It even asked if I wanted help scripting the sounds using free libraries. Very chipper.
For the latter, I'm imagining a sock puppet bursting out of the chest of an adult, who then sing a duet about numbers, while kids joining in for the chorus.
 
Upvote
8 (8 / 0)

Malefor

Smack-Fu Master, in training
30
Our main hope for literature to remain a creative human endeavor is that there is an uncanny valley in writing.
I'm going to disagree with that on a single adjective - it's our main hope for literature to remain a profitable creative human endeavour.
Whether generative software improves or not, whether any technology whatsoever makes their hobbies obsolete, people will always write (and draw, and whatever) just for the fun of it.
No, this possible future won't help those currently earning their living in creative fields, but at least creativity itself will never die until humanity does.
 
Upvote
8 (8 / 0)

juzer

Seniorius Lurkius
47
Is it a thing that erotica authors go around writing and selling individualized stories to individuals on a regular basis for money? I.e. is it anyone's job?

I assume not really, which means AI is actually providing something of value without damaging anyone economically!

Porn and memes, the killer features so far
You know what they say about assumptions? Yeah.

It's becoming and industry on it's own. And it's not important to have author selling to individuals, it's companies providing ability to create their own "private" companion with which they can talk about everything. Yep. Everything.

All things considered OpenAI is late to this game and they have realized they want also that piece of cake because there is a bunch of other solutions anyway. I was also hoping this would stay just a niche because HuggingFace models and AI Reddits show you it's not best obsession to have, imho of course. It does seem to be a huge motivator for people to improve LLM models, for better or for worse.
 
Upvote
2 (3 / -1)

Kirsu

Ars Scholae Palatinae
762
Subscriptor
There's a market for it, but it generally pays less well than drawing pictures - for attention span reasons, I wager, especially when biologically distracted.
That being said, cheap, slop-like porn has always been the killer app for generative neural networks.
Mmmm.. Slop-like porn.
On one hand that sounds so wrong, on the other...
 
Upvote
1 (1 / 0)

Kirsu

Ars Scholae Palatinae
762
Subscriptor
Is it a thing that erotica authors go around writing and selling individualized stories to individuals on a regular basis for money? I.e. is it anyone's job?

I assume not really, which means AI is actually providing something of value without damaging anyone economically!

Porn and memes, the killer features so far
Gotta say, a few AI streamers/side kicks seem pretty damn funny.
I literally lolled a few times watching Can twitch chat beat AI in geoguessr
 
Upvote
1 (2 / -1)
I'm not sure looks matter too much when it comes to text-generating models.

Wait, that gave me a thought. Is there such a thing as an uncanny valley in writing, or is it all "just bad"?
You'll find yourself reading about what kinds of nasty stuff can be done with seventeen fingers and three sets of teeth

ETA: I see now Marlor_AU had a more creative version of this basic idea; good on them!
 
Last edited:
Upvote
6 (6 / 0)
But can it write Bigfoot erotica?

1739622181202.png
 
Upvote
3 (3 / 0)

Dadlyedly

Ars Tribunus Militum
2,551
Subscriptor
There's a market for it, but it generally pays less well than drawing pictures - for attention span reasons, I wager, especially when biologically distracted.
That being said, cheap, slop-like porn has always been the killer app for generative neural networks.
Well, I've been told porn has usually been the driver of new media, so I do have to wonder why LLMs would be any different.
 
Upvote
1 (1 / 0)

mikecee

Ars Scholae Palatinae
1,332
If it's anything like generative imagery, it's going to get interesting.

"Joan held his hand, feeling his fingers enmeshed in hers, those seven digits caressing her hand gently. Without warning, he picked her up and threw her on the bed, face down, nuzzling the back of her neck, kissing the parted lips that lie there. He then climbed upon her, one leg to her left, one to her right, and the other braced against the headboard."
Yes, numbers particularly still seem to be a problem, even small ones. If I ask for three kittens in an image I typically get two or four, and asking for the railway mileage between two towns gave a result that was about half the straight line distance.
The porn's going to have a lot of extra mouths, limbs and genitals popping up, probably in surprising places, which will likely be a turn off for 99% of users (but a real turn on for the remaining 1%).
 
Upvote
9 (9 / 0)

Frank OBrien

Wise, Aged Ars Veteran
131
If it's anything like generative imagery, it's going to get interesting.

"Joan held his hand, feeling his fingers enmeshed in hers, those seven digits caressing her hand gently. Without warning, he picked her up and threw her on the bed, face down, nuzzling the back of her neck, kissing the parted lips that lie there. He then climbed upon her, one leg to her left, one to her right, and the other braced against the headboard."

And.... and.... and... (?!)

This is why I love Ars. Come for the articles, stay for the comments.
 
Upvote
10 (10 / 0)

TheBaconson

Ars Scholae Palatinae
852
Question: in the modern era, is there really that much difference between SATA and SAS disks for bulk storage anymore? I remember SCSI always claimed the mantle of "more reliable" but I've seen so many bulk storage servers using cheaper SATA disks and wonder if it's worth doing SAS for a home server?
To my very limited knowledge, SAS still allows daisy chaining like SCSI did, in terms of transfer rates, I’d only be guessing.
 
Upvote
0 (0 / 0)

Fred Duck

Ars Tribunus Angusticlavius
7,166
Now that you mention it, is there "AI Maternalism?"

ME> Sydney, tell me a joke.
SYDNEY> Okay, but first, are you sleeping enough? You seem a little tired.
ME> I'm fine, now, can I have a joke?
SYDNEY> Dear, you really should get out more and stop spending so much time on the computer.
ME> I think I'll talk with Dad.
CLAUDE> Are there grandkids yet?
 
Last edited:
Upvote
3 (3 / 0)

jerminator

Ars Centurion
353
Subscriptor
Of all of the things to try and keep AI from doing, porn is dead last on my list.... But making it so that all porn is either real armature porn made as a labor of love, or as custom AI generated wank bait? Great.

Armature porn? You're really winding me up.
I'll see myself out now.
 
Upvote
3 (3 / 0)

FinallyAnAccount

Ars Scholae Palatinae
1,459
Subscriptor
99% of written erotica online is very bad, so on the one hand the bar is low. On the other hand, it's probably going to become 99.999% of written erotica online being very bad.

But in the future, I could see a system where you feed/train an AI on all of your favorite erotica and books and pictures and videos and then use prompts to get something novel enough that it might be arousing? Not sure how long that will take though.
 
Upvote
0 (0 / 0)

TrentaDespresso

Smack-Fu Master, in training
1
Writing (on an alt, for obvious reasons) as someone who does write erotica/kink for money (though like someone mentioned upthread, not as my primary source of income), this doesn't have me particularly worried.

It does remind me of a time me and a few other writers/artists hucked a bunch of our stuff into NovelAI when the generative AI craze was first taking out and having a good laugh about the results.

As someone mentioned, an awful lot of what's out there is bad, and easy access to AI-generated slop is going to make that proportion marginally higher than it already is. But people who are willing to pay for specific and tailored stories were already going to be a more picky bunch to begin with, and they're going to be extra disinclined to read stories that "spoil the mood" with implausible anatomy.

I certainly haven't noticed any impact to my business, but in fairness I've never been operating at demand level due to health reasons so it's possible that the demand curve has ah, softened.
 
Upvote
5 (5 / 0)
sensitive personal data
No AI chat should be able to output sensitive personal data because it should never have seen any.
how to build a bomb, make illegal drugs
For that we already have a ton of resources, don't we? Especially the first one isn't difficult to find at all.
or manipulate political views
I'm not sure if the "how to" applied to that - if it does - well, there are tons of books about influencing people and none of them are deemed too hazardous. As for generating manipulative content - I certainly agree, but I'm not sure how enforceable it is without outright banning any political criticism.
 
Upvote
0 (0 / 0)

equals42

Ars Scholae Palatinae
1,215
Subscriptor++
To my very limited knowledge, SAS still allows daisy chaining like SCSI did, in terms of transfer rates, I’d only be guessing.
SAS is a better protocol than SATA but that’s been massively improved upon by NVMe. SAS disks are also usually double bussed so redundant controllers can be connected to them but it’s overkill for most use cases. There’s usually multiple lanes of SAS in cables as well so you can parallelize out of the HBA into an enclosure but again, why at home unless you get one cheap.
If I could get a reasonably priced SAS enclosure I have access to tons of SAS disks (spinning and SSD) in my line of work. It just wouldn’t run Synology (unless I buy theirs for a fortune) so it would end up an other home science project that I don’t want to do anymore. [Unless it’s instructional for my career like screwing around with containers or RAGs recently.]
 
Upvote
0 (0 / 0)