Ukraine is game to you? Part deux.

Technarch

Ars Legatus Legionis
14,932
Subscriptor

dzid

Ars Centurion
3,235
Subscriptor
I know this is lowbrow humor, but I ran across this on a Ukrainian news service (NEXTA). The caption is:

"The savior's TV channel is broken. Oops, or should that be the case? The sign on the building of the Orthodox TV channel 'Spas' has broken, and now the name glows not at all as intended. A new slogan?"

New Orthodox TV slogan?

I'm claiming relevance due to the fact that the Ukrainians felt it important enough to ban the Orthodox church in Ukraine as it was a front for Russian influence operations. As such, it seems it is not only fair game for ridicule, but effective propaganda. Humor in time of war at the enemy's expense for a weary population.

My knowledge of the Ukrainian alphabet extends only far enough to read YouTube video titles (which feels like an indictment of me), but I think that sign would read something like
'Anal Snack?'
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Bonusround

Matisaro

Ars Legatus Legionis
24,203
Subscriptor
I mean, they certainly outright say they're at war with The West often enough...

They have been conducting psy ops on us through social media for years now, it is causing real damage. We should have cut the fuckers off of the internet a decade ago.
 

KGFish

Ars Legatus Legionis
13,205
Subscriptor++
It's incredible how we all pretend Russia isn't actively at war with the West.


View: https://bsky.app/profile/maks23.bsky.social/post/3lxwbckks5s26

Since the BlueSky post doesn't have the link to the original post (I really hope the Ukraine OSINTers get that habit under control, because it is one way that misinformation spreads very easily), here's the PDF:
https://www.iiss.org/globalassets/m...-the-scale-of-russian-sabotage-operations.pdf

For people who haven't read it yet, it's a good summary of all the bullshit that has Russian fingerprints all over it. Provides a lot of context to that particular infographic.

Like, for example, Gotland AGAIN having mysteriously lost all power. Though to be fair, that particular bit happens pretty often and at least the last two incidents were traced to lightning and a technical fault. But for anyone who reads Swedish, this may be good to confirm. Because for God's sake Google, Xitter is NOT an authoritative source on ANYTHING. Stop linking your AI summaries to it.
 

Lt_Storm

Ars Tribunus Angusticlavius
20,019
Subscriptor++
just eyeballing the map (I'm not going to count them) it looks like >50% of the incidents are "realistically possible" or "likely" incidents of "Spying by uninhabited aerial vehicles" or "Vandalism"

EDIT - There's also two (that I see) markers for "Weaponized Immigration".
The things is that, in the security industry, at least with regard to cyber warfare, it is pretty common knowledge that Russia has been attacking America and Europe since at least 2008. We've been talking about the bears for a long time now.
 

Technarch

Ars Legatus Legionis
14,932
Subscriptor
The things is that, in the security industry, at least with regard to cyber warfare, it is pretty common knowledge that Russia has been attacking America and Europe since at least 2008. We've been talking about the bears for a long time now.

Yeah this is what irritates me. I'm in cyber and I've been fighting these obvious Russian sabotage campaigns for two decades. It's beyond infuriating that these open attacks were just fucking ignored for so long. And now here we are.
 
Since the BlueSky post doesn't have the link to the original post (I really hope the Ukraine OSINTers get that habit under control, because it is one way that misinformation spreads very easily), here's the PDF:
https://www.iiss.org/globalassets/m...-the-scale-of-russian-sabotage-operations.pdf

For people who haven't read it yet, it's a good summary of all the bullshit that has Russian fingerprints all over it. Provides a lot of context to that particular infographic.

Like, for example, Gotland AGAIN having mysteriously lost all power. Though to be fair, that particular bit happens pretty often and at least the last two incidents were traced to lightning and a technical fault. But for anyone who reads Swedish, this may be good to confirm. Because for God's sake Google, Xitter is NOT an authoritative source on ANYTHING. Stop linking your AI summaries to it.
Gotland lost power for about an hour a few days ago due to lightning strikes. While the poor state of transmission capacity to Gotland, and within Sweden in general, can certainly be a security issue itself, I'm not sure we can blame either thunder storms or shitty regulation of the power grid market on Russia...
 

Alexander

Ars Legatus Legionis
13,930
Subscriptor
The things is that, in the security industry, at least with regard to cyber warfare, it is pretty common knowledge that Russia has been attacking America and Europe since at least 2008. We've been talking about the bears for a long time now.
Yeah this is what irritates me. I'm in cyber and I've been fighting these obvious Russian sabotage campaigns for two decades. It's beyond infuriating that these open attacks were just fucking ignored for so long. And now here we are.

That's not what the article or the map are about. It describes a mostly "gig-economy" style approach (paying locals to do stuff), mostly but not entirely focused on monitoring and disrupting flow of military aid to Ukraine (e.g. paying local patsies to place cameras along rail lines used to transport AFVs). It covers 2018-2025 with a handful of incidents from 2018-2021 then kicking off in 2022 with the invasion and really ramping up in 2024:

More recently, Russian sabotage operations in Europe have increased their range of targets and severity of attacks. The number of attacks almost quadrupled from 2023 to 2024 (see Figure 1). IISS data shows that the most frequent ECI targets are facilities linked to the war in Ukraine and government facilities.7 Russia targets bases, production facilities and those facilities involved in transporting military aid to Ukraine.

Also spends some time preaching about the generally fragile and neglected state of infrastructure in Europe, and lack of a united response. Sources for the individual incidents are OSINT.


EDIT - 'mostly' gig economy
 
Last edited:

dzid

Ars Centurion
3,235
Subscriptor
Source: Obozrevatel.ua (Ukrainian news outlet)

It seems that the American president is concerned about a Ukrainian woman, Iryna Zartsuka, who was murdered in Charlotte, NC, by "a crazed monster who was free to roam after 144 arrests" This is indeed a tragedy. Why not show similar concern and support for those in Ukraine?
 

goates

Ars Praefectus
3,261
Subscriptor++
Poland has reportedly shot down Russian drones that crossed into Polish airspace. About time.

Poland said it scrambled its own and NATO air defences to shoot down drones on Wednesday after a Russian air attack on western Ukraine, the first time in the Ukraine war that Warsaw has engaged assets in its airspace.
Poland's military command said drones repeatedly violated Polish airspace during the Russian attack across the border in Ukraine, and the defence minister said NATO command had been briefed.

Radars tracked more than 10 objects and those that could pose a threat were "neutralised," the command said.
"Some of the drones that entered our airspace were shot down. Searches and efforts to locate the potential crash sites of these objects are ongoing," it said in a statement.

https://www.reuters.com/business/ae...ace-during-russian-attack-ukraine-2025-09-09/
 

wireframed

Ars Legatus Legionis
17,268
Subscriptor
I realize why it’s not so easy, but I wish the EU countries would adopt the same approach to Russia that Türkiye used when it shot down Russian fighters provoking them by strafing into their airspace.

Russia is an expert at trolling, and things that should be considered acts of aggression, such as cyberattacks, but which they have just enough deniability for, that they can whine about “Russophobia” when they’re accused.

They only do this because they know EU won’t react in a meaningful way.

Instead, we should adopt the approach of Malone in the Untouchables. Swift retribution - they hack a power station, we destroy one of theirs. They violate airspace, despite fair warning? We destroy the plane. And so on.

It’s all the Putin admin understands. Strength.
 

dizdizzie

Ars Scholae Palatinae
1,407
Poland needs to react very strongly otherwise Russia will keep escalating. The hybrid war is ongoing for years. In May 2024 huge shopping center was completely burnt down in Warsaw by Russian agents. There are migrants being flown to Belarus and later sent to our and Baltic states borders (very controversial issue). Strange "objects" fly to Poland and crash from time to time. Now this.

For broader context there are military drills in Belarus. Border with Belarus will be closed since Friday IIRC.

The attacks will continue and at some point Russia will say. OK we will stop sending migrants or attacking you with drones or something like that if you stop sending weapons to Ukraine or stop sanctions. This is why Poland and NATO reaction must be very, very strong. Otherwise we will reach the point where Russia will openly ask for concessions.

As for tonight's attacks. My colleague from work has family near Zamość. It's South-East Poland not far away from Lviv. There is radar installation nearby built in 2011. It could have been a target. For them it felt like a war. There were a lot planes, helicopters in the air, even windows were shaking. I hope this isn't new normal. Not that long time ago war near our border felt unreal, now we got used to it. What's next?
 

Technarch

Ars Legatus Legionis
14,932
Subscriptor
Poland needs to react very strongly otherwise Russia will keep escalating. The hybrid will is ongoing for years. In may 2024 huge shopping center was completely burnt down in Warsaw by Russian agents. There are migrants being flown to Belarus and later send to our and Baltic states borders. Strange "objects" fly to Poland from time to time. Now this.

For broader context there are military drills in Belarus. Border with Belarus will be closed since Friday IIRC.

The attacks will continue and at some point Russia will say. OK we will stop sending migrants or attacking you with drones or something like that if you stop sending weapons to Ukraine or stop sanctions. This is why Poland and NATO reaction must be very, very strong. Otherwise we will reach the point where Russia will openly ask for concessions.

As for tonight's attacks. My colleague from work has family near Zamość. It's South-East Poland not far away from Lviv. There is radar installation nearby built in 2011. It could have been a target. For them it felt like a war. There were a lot planes, helicopters in the air, even windows were shaking. I hope this isn't new normal. Not that long time ago war near our border felt unreal, now we got used to it. What's next?

This. It's clearly a deliberate attempt by Putin to normalize attacks on EU countries. The creeping gradualism will continue until the bully gets punched in the nose. Fortunately, this attack was significant enough to justify an actual response. Hopefully the Poles will take advantage of the opportunity.
 

tigas

Ars Tribunus Angusticlavius
7,361
Subscriptor
Zapad joint Belarus/Russia military exercise is happening or about to happen next door, and Gerbera drones can carry SIM cards to transmit intelligence in real-time. If they find any Polish SIM cards in the wreckage, that'll prove premeditation. But I'm sure Russia is testing NATO's defences.
NATO deployed an F-35 serving as AEW&C, a tanker (Dutch?) to refuel it, and I hope also other assets that weren't squawking.

Edit to add: hearsay claims 19 23 drones crossed into Poland. Even for a 600+ 400+ salvo, that's hardly an accident.
 
Last edited:

dio82

Ars Legatus Legionis
10,307
Subscriptor
Poland needs to react very strongly otherwise Russia will keep escalating. The hybrid war is ongoing for years. In May 2024 huge shopping center was completely burnt down in Warsaw by Russian agents. There are migrants being flown to Belarus and later sent to our and Baltic states borders (very controversial issue). Strange "objects" fly to Poland and crash from time to time. Now this.

For broader context there are military drills in Belarus. Border with Belarus will be closed since Friday IIRC.

The attacks will continue and at some point Russia will say. OK we will stop sending migrants or attacking you with drones or something like that if you stop sending weapons to Ukraine or stop sanctions. This is why Poland and NATO reaction must be very, very strong. Otherwise we will reach the point where Russia will openly ask for concessions.

As for tonight's attacks. My colleague from work has family near Zamość. It's South-East Poland not far away from Lviv. There is radar installation nearby built in 2011. It could have been a target. For them it felt like a war. There were a lot planes, helicopters in the air, even windows were shaking. I hope this isn't new normal. Not that long time ago war near our border felt unreal, now we got used to it. What's next?
I sincerely hope that this will finally get EU nations unstick their thumbs from their arses and to finally actively patrol western Ukraine with airforce assets and to proactively shoot anything down that doesn't belong there.
 
I sincerely hope that this will finally get EU nations unstick their thumbs from their arses and to finally actively patrol western Ukraine with airforce assets and to proactively shoot anything down that doesn't belong there.
This. It seems like the safest way to hurt Russian war plans. Make Russian provocation have a cost that Russia must pay. Patrol Ukrainian skies to block missile/drone attacks. And give the NATO pilots some training for conflicts to come. Win-win.

There may be contingency plans for this, but I imagine the complexities of coordinating with multiple air defense systems to prevent friendly fire are substantial.
 

dio82

Ars Legatus Legionis
10,307
Subscriptor
This. It seems like the safest way to hurt Russian war plans. Make Russian provocation have a cost that Russia must pay. Patrol Ukrainian skies to block missile/drone attacks. And give the NATO pilots some training for conflicts to come. Win-win.

There may be contingency plans for this, but I imagine the complexities of coordinating with multiple air defense systems to prevent friendly fire are substantial.
It would probably mean grounding MIG-29s and SU-25s, only stuff with Link-16 and NATO FoF can fly
 
Last edited:
It would mean grounding MIG-29s and SU-25s, only stuff with Link-16 and NATO FoF can fly
Yeah, that is problematic.

Not sure how much of the Ukrainian AF that is at this point, but probably most of it. It doesn't seem likely that it is possible to segment the airspace either, as I imagine the Ukrainian planes are as far West as possible to avoid being wiped out in Russian strikes.
 
I have to agree that the current situation wherein every western decision is put against the potential threat of escalation whereas Russia just does whatever the fuck it wants, wherever it wants, whenever it wants and basically dares the west to meaningfully respond (which it almost never does) is inherently untenable.

It's high past time we gave the Russians a damn good fucking reason to worry about escalation.
 

dio82

Ars Legatus Legionis
10,307
Subscriptor
Honestly, fuck this shit. It is now kinetic time. Russia sent more than 20 drones whith active routing within Poland (no ewar deviations) and these drones had polish SIM cards. It is time to strike Shahed launchers in Russia and to impose an embargo and total RF blackout on Kaliningrad.
 
Besides my default stance of giving the Ukrainians literally every single thing they ask for from US stockpiles, I would argue for an immediate no-fly zone within 100 km of Ukrainian and all NATO countries' airspace. You come close to a border, we shoot you down. You light up our air units on radar, we take out the radar. Period.
 

Wheels Of Confusion

Ars Legatus Legionis
75,415
Subscriptor
I thought this deserved to be posted here from the front page unofficial thread:

Continuing my morning round-up of war crimes: Russian camps to indoctrinate Ukrainian kids.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2...-fight-for-it-i-understood-it-wasnt-just-play

Last summer, Sonya*, aged 17 at the time, had endured more than two years of a difficult life under Russian occupation in the Kherson region of southern Ukraine. Her foster mother agreed that she needed a break.

Growing up under forced assimilation had been scary, Sonya says, and her Russian-controlled school had offered to take her to a holiday camp in Crimea, a balmy peninsula once famed for being the spa of the Soviet Union.

It was only after they had left that she discovered they were actually being taken to Volgograd, a city more than 600 miles (1,000km) away in the south-west of Russia. Far from being a holiday resort, the city is home to one of a growing number of state-run military-style training camps held for Ukrainian and Russian children.

Sonya spent a month at the Avangard camp, which has several other branches across Russia, and had sanctions imposed on it by the UK in November for its role in the forced deportation and brainwashing of Ukrainian children. She says she and other children faced a programme of activities that included being taught to dig trenches and rig them with booby traps and trip wires, load machine guns, take part in military-style formations and carry other children on their backs to simulate medical evacuations.

Similar to Soviet-era youth camps, these centres have escalated in number since the start of the full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022. Critics say they are used to indoctrinate children to prepare them for future service in the Russian military.

Now large numbers of children from occupied regions of Ukraine are reportedly being sent alongside the young Russians. The Kremlin portrays these facilities as physical and cultural learning opportunities for children.

“The instructors told me that with the certificate given after the training, you can join the Russian army, so I understood it wasn’t just play,” says Sonya. “I was so worried because I knew I would turn 18 soon and could be forced to sign up.”
It's not just about preparing them to fight, it's also about indoctrinating them into Putin's service, and stripping them of Ukrainian identity.
Sonya and her family had to take Russian passports and other documents, and at school she had to study the Russian curriculum and language. Her younger brother was also sent to an Avangard camp, where she says he fell victim to the indoctrination.

“After being subjected to their propaganda, he took Russia’s side,” she says. “He says he will join the Russian army. He talks about it with his friends.”
[...]
After her stint in the military camp, Sonya, now 18, returned to her foster family in an occupied part of Kherson. Scared that she would be forced to return to the camp, she managed to escape earlier this year with the help of Save Ukraine to Kyiv. Her brother has stayed behind in Kherson.
Camp rules circulating on social media suggest children are banned from speaking “foreign” languages, such as Ukrainian, and from wearing the yellow and blue colours of Ukraine’s flag. Contact with family is often limited.

Sonya says staff at her camp punished Ukrainian boys for disobedience by ordering them to strip to their underwear and perform intense physical exercise. She says they also often used a derogatory Russian term for Ukrainians.
And because it's Russia, abuse is mandatory.
Ukrainian children in occupied territories are often given little choice about attending, says Megan Gittoes, from the GlobSec thinktank, with conditions at the camps for them frequently abusive – physically, mentally and psychologically. Gittoes says she has documented boys being forced to box each other or endure beatings.

“Children are forced into these programmes or their parents risk losing custody. It’s explicitly coercive. Ukrainian children face harsher indoctrination because their identity has to be erased. The aim is to instil fear, dependence on the state and loyalty to Russia,” she says.
 
NATO deployed an F-35 serving as AEW&C, a tanker (Dutch?) to refuel it, and I hope also other assets that weren't squawking.
The tanker is quite likely to be registered Dutch, but they're operating under NATOs Multinational Multi Role Tanker Transport Unit. The aircraft (12 total in future iirc) are jointly owned by 6 different countries (Netherlands, Germany, Belgium, Luxembourgh, Norway, Czechia). NATO is supporting the ongoing air security missions in the region by basically operating all their tanker training flights over there. It's good practice for the pilots and operators and everybody still gets to operate "their" hours on the aircraft.

The same A330 MRTT aircraft are also operated by the UK, France and Spain and I've seen those visiting the main base for the MMRTTU at Eindhoven Airport too. Germany has some slightly smaller A310 MRTTs too.
 
From Putin's perspective, this might be the best time to start a fight with NATO. EU countries are in the process of rearming, but they don't have their new weapons yet. America won't back them up. This gap between the dropping of the US shield and preparation to stand alone is his best chance. Chaos in France also helps, as they have the nukes.

A dangerous moment.
 

meisanerd

Ars Praetorian
1,464
Subscriptor
Donald Trump has called on the European Union (EU) to hit China and India with tariffs of up to 100% to force Russian president Vladimir Putin to end the war in Ukraine.

The US president made the demand during a meeting between US and EU officials on Tuesday discussing options to increase economic pressure on Russia, a source familiar with the discussions has told the BBC.
https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c80gvz3l7n2o

You know what else would help? Sending Ukraine the military resources they need to push the Russian's out of their country, instead of doing the whole "on again, off again" relationship with Putin, and all the "if Putin doesn't cooperate, bad things* will happen" talk (*bad things being waiting a few weeks, then repeating the threat).

Biden slow-walked the military support for Ukraine, with the arbitrary restrictions that they could only use American-provided long-range weapons on Ukrainian territory instead of letting them hit Russian military targets. If Trump wants to fix this, give Ukraine weapons and intel to let them better cripple the Russian MIC, that would have worked a whole lot better at doing the whole "I will end the war in a day" nonsense...
 

dio82

Ars Legatus Legionis
10,307
Subscriptor
From Putin's perspective, this might be the best time to start a fight with NATO. EU countries are in the process of rearming, but they don't have their new weapons yet. America won't back them up. This gap between the dropping of the US shield and preparation to stand alone is his best chance. Chaos in France also helps, as they have the nukes.

A dangerous moment.
Russia has nothing with which to attack. They are all in Ukraine. Some air force is left and their rusted naval hulls. Now is the time escalate on EU side because Russia has nothing and their economy is on the verge of collapse.
 

Zod

Ars Praefectus
4,724
Subscriptor++
From Putin's perspective, this might be the best time to start a fight with NATO. EU countries are in the process of rearming, but they don't have their new weapons yet. America won't back them up. This gap between the dropping of the US shield and preparation to stand alone is his best chance. Chaos in France also helps, as they have the nukes.

A dangerous moment.
Attack with what?

If Russia didn’t have nuclear weapons, this would be the perfect time for Europe to attack Russia and depose Putin. All he has is nuclear blackmail.
 
Russia has nothing with which to attack. They are all in Ukraine. Some air force is left and their rusted naval hulls. Now is the time escalate on EU side because Russia has nothing and their economy is on the verge of collapse.
Let's go Finland! Some incursions into their airspace, spook them, make them send more resources to the endless border far away from Ukraine.
 
Russia has nothing with which to attack. They are all in Ukraine. Some air force is left and their rusted naval hulls. Now is the time escalate on EU side because Russia has nothing and their economy is on the verge of collapse.
But yes, not sure what game Putin is playing here. Create political divisions in EU countries? He isn't a total idiot, I don't think.
 

tigas

Ars Tribunus Angusticlavius
7,361
Subscriptor
Honestly, fuck this shit. It is now kinetic time. Russia sent more than 20 drones whith active routing within Poland (no ewar deviations) and these drones had polish SIM cards. It is time to strike Shahed launchers in Russia and to impose an embargo and total RF blackout on Kaliningrad.
I saw someone mentioning it on BlueSky but I couldn't find a source.

https://united24media.com/latest-ne...era-drones-really-looking-for-in-poland-11535
According to Defense Express, Polish SIM cards had been detected on Russian drones since July, suggesting that reconnaissance may have been a primary objective of the incursion. [..]
Analysis of reported crash sites shows that five drones fell along the Biała Podlaska–Parczew line. This area hosts three major roadways: the E30 motorway, and highways 63 and 82, which connect toward central Poland.

Other drones were observed north of Lublin, near the defense industry hub of Stalowa Wola, and west of Białystok. One drone was found as far as Łódź.

The routes also intersected with Polish air defense infrastructure. Two of the country’s long-range radar posts—Roskosz with an NUR-12M radar and Labunie with a RAT-31DL system—are situated along these paths.
The Defence Express article says, though:
https://en.defence-ua.com/news/krem...russian_uavs_with_polish_sim_cards-15775.html
Whether the drones that attacked Poland today were equipped with such systems remains unknown. However, it is reasonable to assume that one of the purposes of the russian attack was to gather intelligence on Poland's air defense systems, especially considering that on September 12, joint russian-belarusian military exercises Zapad-2025 are scheduled to begin on Belarusian territory.
But yeah, Russia is always thinking about war, and they've remembered to get prepared properly after the mad rush to Kyiv got them smacked hard. Russia learning from its mistakes has been a constant in this war, while NATO has been learning from Ukraine but it's not the same as learning from mistakes. Moreover, I hope our militaries are working on resilience and reconstitution, because I fear we may have a glass jaw and if our initial forces get their asses handed to them due to lack of experience, we may not have a second wave ready to go and apply the new knowledge. And the pressure to surrender will be immense.
 

karolus

Ars Legatus Legionis
10,706
Subscriptor++
Attack with what?

If Russia didn’t have nuclear weapons, this would be the perfect time for Europe to attack Russia and depose Putin. All he has is nuclear blackmail.
To quote Colin Powell in regards to the Invasion of Iraq: You break it, you buy it.

It's easy to be sitting behind a keyboard and suggesting regime change, but another to actually be doing it. It has a number of high risks. One of them is rallying indifferent members of a population in support of the leadership against the invaders. Whoever would succeed Putin would have a major benefit when stepping in—an energized populace, and valid excuse to rearm.

Invasions and occupations are a major endeavor. How well did Iraq and Afghanistan go for the US, and so far, Ukraine for Russia?