Skip to content
Fellowship of the dollars

As OpenAI launches $500B “Stargate” project, critics express skepticism

Elon Musk questions funding for massive AI infrastructure project; Altman defends financial backing.

Benj Edwards | 314
U.S. President Donald Trump speaks in the Roosevelt Room of the White House while SoftBank CEO Masayoshi Son, Oracle CTO Larry Ellison, and OpenAI CEO Sam Altman look on on January 21, 2025 in Washington, DC.
US President Donald Trump speaks in the Roosevelt Room of the White House while SoftBank CEO Masayoshi Son, Oracle CTO Larry Ellison, and OpenAI CEO Sam Altman look on on January 21, 2025, in Washington, DC. Credit: Andrew Harnik via Getty Images
US President Donald Trump speaks in the Roosevelt Room of the White House while SoftBank CEO Masayoshi Son, Oracle CTO Larry Ellison, and OpenAI CEO Sam Altman look on on January 21, 2025, in Washington, DC. Credit: Andrew Harnik via Getty Images
Story text

On Tuesday, OpenAI, SoftBank, Oracle, and MGX announced plans to form Stargate, a new company that will invest $500 billion in AI computing infrastructure across the United States over four years. The announcement came during a White House meeting with President Donald Trump, who called it the “largest AI infrastructure project in history.”

However, the origins of the Stargate project extend back to 2024, prior to Trump beginning his second term in office, and skeptics have begun to take aim at the numbers announced.

OpenAI says the goal of Stargate is to kickstart building more data centers to expand computing capacity for current and future AI projects, including OpenAI’s goal of “AGI,” which the company defines as a highly autonomous AI system that “outperforms humans at most economically valuable work.”

“This infrastructure will secure American leadership in AI, create hundreds of thousands of American jobs, and generate massive economic benefit for the entire world,” claimed OpenAI in a press statement. “This project will not only support the re-industrialization of the United States but also provide a strategic capability to protect the national security of America and its allies.”

On Tuesday, Altman appeared at a White House press conference to announce Stargate alongside President Trump, Oracle CEO Larry Ellison, and SoftBank CEO Masayoshi Son. During his turn at the microphone, Altman said he thinks Stargate represents “the most important project of this era,” allowing AGI to emerge in the United States. He believes that future AI technology could create hundreds of thousands of jobs. “We wouldn’t be able to do this without you, Mr. President,” Altman added.

Responding to off-camera questions from Trump about AI’s potential to spur scientific development, Altman said he believes AI will accelerate the discoveries for cures of diseases like cancer and heart disease.

Video of the Stargate announcement conference at the White House.

OpenAI says that SoftBank will handle financial operations for Stargate while OpenAI manages technical operations. Masayoshi Son, SoftBank’s CEO, will serve as chairman. The partnership includes technology collaborations with Arm, Microsoft, and Nvidia. Notably, MGX is part of Abu Dhabi’s push into AI investments, backed by substantial sovereign wealth from the United Arab Emirates.

The new Stargate company will reportedly start with $100 billion, which will be used to construct data centers and computing systems. Oracle’s CEO Larry Ellison mentioned during the press conference that the new company has already begun building its first facility, a large data center in Abilene, Texas. Notably, the US government has not announced any government dollars directly invested in the project.

The Stargate announcement wasn’t Trump’s only major AI-related move this week. It follows the newly inaugurated president’s reversal of a 2023 Biden executive order on AI risk monitoring and regulation.

An older project with a Trump stamp of approval

Despite the Trump tie-in for the most recent announcement, the “Stargate” name and some elemental aspects of the project trace their origins to last year. In March 2024, The Information and Reuters reported that Microsoft and OpenAI jointly planned a $100 billion supercomputer called “Stargate,” which would be the final part of a five-phase plan set to launch in 2028.

Since then, some gaps have begun to appear between Microsoft and OpenAI’s multi-billion-dollar partnership. On Tuesday, Microsoft announced that OpenAI may now seek cloud providers for its AI services outside of Microsoft’s Azure datacenters, although Microsoft still has right of first refusal to provide services. This allowance comes at an opportune time for OpenAI’s new Stargate venture, of which Microsoft is not joint owner.

However, not long after that news broke on Tuesday, OpenAI CEO Sam Altman wrote on X that Microsoft and OpenAI were not parting ways, saying that it’s a “very important and huge partnership, for a long time to come.”

Critics take aim, Musk expresses skepticism

Some frequent OpenAI critics, like tech writer Ed Zitron, have already begun to question whether Stargate can come up with the initial $100 billion in funds, much less the $500 billion they expect to raise over time.

After The Information reported that OpenAI and SoftBank have each committed $19 billion to the new venture, Zitron wrote on BlueSky, referencing OpenAI’s $5 billion in losses in 2024, “Oh my god, this is completely ridiculous. OpenAI will raise another $19bn in debt/equity? This company loses $5bn+ a year! So what, they raise $19bn for Stargate, then what, another $10bn just to be able to survive?”

 

Screenshots of Elon Musk challenging the Stargate announcement on X.
Screenshots of Elon Musk challenging the Stargate announcement on X.
Screenshots of Elon Musk challenging the Stargate announcement on X.

Not long after the Stargate announcement on Tuesday, Trump ally and frequent Altman foe Elon Musk immediately attacked the Stargate plan on X, writing, “They don’t actually have the money,” and following up with a claim that we cannot substantiate, saying, “SoftBank has well under $10B secured. I have that on good authority.”

Musk’s criticism has complex implications given his very close ties to Trump, his history of litigating against OpenAI (which he co-founded and later left), and his own goals with his xAI company.

On Wednesday morning, Altman replied on X that he “genuinely respects” Musk’s accomplishments and said he thinks Musk is “the most inspiring entrepreneur of our time.”

Altman also addressed Musk’s claims about not having the claimed money amounts, saying, “wrong, as you surely know. want to come visit the first site already under way? this is great for the country. i realize what is great for the country isn’t always what’s optimal for your companies, but in your new role i hope you’ll mostly put 🇺🇸 first.”

This article was updated on January 23, 2025, to include details about OpenAI’s 2024 “Stargate” plan with Microsoft. It also adds criticism from Ed Zitron and more information about Sam Altman’s response to Musk’s criticism.

Photo of Benj Edwards
Benj Edwards Senior AI Reporter
Benj Edwards was a reporter at Ars Technica covering artificial intelligence and technology history.
314 Comments