New Spotify report debunks “per stream” payments for artists

In a report published Tuesday, Spotify revealed the inner workings of its payout systems for artists with music available on the service. The company debunked the claim that the service pays per stream, revealing that things are slightly more complex.

Rather than a flat rate per play of a song, Spotify considers the success of an artist relative to the entire Spotify ecosystem to determine how much money they get. Royalties for, say, one song are paid out based on the proportion of plays it gets out of all of the plays Spotify doles out in a given time period.

There are other factors to the payout formula. How much revenue Spotify earns in a month determines the total amount of royalty money available on a country-by-country basis. After that, Spotify does the math on how much traffic a given artist constituted for the month. For instance, if Spotify has $100 in royalty money from one country and an artist represented 0.01 percent of that month’s streams, the payout for that country would be 0.01 cents.

Popularity is everything.

Of that proportion, Spotify keeps 30 percent for itself, and 70 percent goes to the “master and publishing owners.” So if the music is owned by a label, the 70 percent goes there; if the music is owned by the artist, the payout goes directly to the artist. The 70 percent figure appears to be a bit flexible. Spotify writes in the post that it “negotiates… royalty economics with labels and publishers in each territory.” From there, if the artist operates on a royalty rate under their label, the artist is then paid out of that 70 percent of the tiny proportion of money their music represents in Spotify’s overall traffic.

The report comes as a response to individual artists reporting the money they’ve earned from the service, which often appears to be piddling and is almost always reported as “per stream.” Musician Zoe Keating revealed in August that she earned $808 from 201,412 streams of her two albums on Spotify, a return of 0.4 cents per play, during the first six months of 2013.

According to Spotify’s accounting, Keating’s return is low. Spotify claims that it’s putting out “an average ‘per stream’ payout to rights holders of between $0.006 and $0.0084” (0.6 to 0.84 cents). And while a per-stream rate can be reverse-engineered from an artist’s total payout, Spotify was actually using the proportional system above to determine payout instead of the sheer number of plays.

Artists have noted in the past that Spotify appears to pay differently per stream depending on whether that stream was by a paid-premium user or a user whose listening is ad-supported. Spotify states that this is a factor in determining the overall revenue pot, but the company doesn’t include it in the formula for determining the revenue per artist.

In November 2012, musician Damon Krukowski wrote on Pitchfork that Spotify negotiated royalty rates individually for each label, and that his label received the “going ‘indie’ rate” of 0.5 cents per play. This was then adjusted per some of the factors above outlined in “small, invisible print,” like the number of listeners who are subscribers vs. ad-supported. Krukowski wrote that this meant Spotify should have owed his label $29.80 for 5,960 plays; instead, he was paid $9.18.

Spotify’s story doesn’t quite account for this alleged process, so it’s unclear whether its method changed since last year or if “going rates” are given as a sort of ballpark figure to set expectations. When asked about Krukowski’s account, Graham James, head of US communications for Spotify, told Ars that “the amount that labels get from Spotify is the same across labels.” James continued, “I don’t know where he got that information from… it’s incorrect if he’s saying he negotiated a per-stream rate.”

In its report, Spotify goes on to give estimates on what artists of different profiles can expect to earn. Using real, anonymized figures, Spotify states that a “niche indie album” earned $3,300 for the month of July 2013, while a “global hit album” earned $425,000.

Payouts for different types of albums in July 2013, alongside what Spotify estimates it will be able to pay once it hits 40 million subscribers.

Credit: Spotify

Spotify only specifies in the report that these were “actual” numbers, but not whether they were any kind of average or whether the albums were new or recent releases. Mark Williamson of Spotify Artist Services tells Ars that “one [album] is a current top 10 [on] Spotify, one is a current global hit—they’re all fairly current.” The Independent writes that the Daft Punk single “Get Lucky” alone earned $1.08 million on 78.6 million plays.