Jon Snow's fate still in limbo, plus other main characters now seem imperilled.
Read the whole story
Read the whole story
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30649227#p30649227:1wzmdenc said:sanloublues[/url]":1wzmdenc]Any major reasons I couldn't or shouldn't switch from the books to the show at this point without watching the previous seasons? Besides all the characters being grownups who don't look like my imagination, I mean
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30650027#p30650027:279mf2fh said:r venosa[/url]":279mf2fh]I'm sure the dragonglass will also come in very handy, too![url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30649833#p30649833:279mf2fh said:Meailda[/url]":279mf2fh][url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30649613#p30649613:279mf2fh said:trollhunter[/url]":279mf2fh]A weird thought just passed by my mind.
In any other case I would just shrug it, but it's GoT we are talking about...
What if the planned outcome never was a human victory ? I mean, what if GRRM planned all the time the White Walkers to defeat and convert everything at the end ?
Then you wouldn't have had the dragons show up. Their purpose is to be the weapon against the night.
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30648917#p30648917:23opp2ie said:tigas[/url]":23opp2ie]Surely George RR Martin wouldn't kill off everyone's favourite remaining characters?
How long have you been following this story, exactly?I mean, really.
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30650027#p30650027:u9740990 said:r venosa[/url]":u9740990]I'm sure the dragonglass will also come in very handy, too![url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30649833#p30649833:u9740990 said:Meailda[/url]":u9740990][url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30649613#p30649613:u9740990 said:trollhunter[/url]":u9740990]A weird thought just passed by my mind.
In any other case I would just shrug it, but it's GoT we are talking about...
What if the planned outcome never was a human victory ? I mean, what if GRRM planned all the time the White Walkers to defeat and convert everything at the end ?
Then you wouldn't have had the dragons show up. Their purpose is to be the weapon against the night.
I can't imagine any person interested in Game of Thrones skipping the amazing first season. If he's read the book, no reason to check out the entire series. Sean Bean's performance is worth the price of admission, alone.[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30649881#p30649881:u9740990 said:BuckBuchanan[/url]":u9740990]As good as it is, you could probably skip season 1 as it is very faithful to the book. But you should definitely watch season 5, and probably 2-4, too.[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30649227#p30649227:u9740990 said:sanloublues[/url]":u9740990]Any major reasons I couldn't or shouldn't switch from the books to the show at this point without watching the previous seasons? Besides all the characters being grownups who don't look like my imagination, I mean
Then again, I've probably watched that first season at least 10 times in its entirety. And now with season 6 approaching, looks like a 5-season binge-watching session is in order...
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30649227#p30649227:30xfli5y said:sanloublues[/url]":30xfli5y]Any major reasons I couldn't or shouldn't switch from the books to the show at this point without watching the previous seasons? Besides all the characters being grownups who don't look like my imagination, I mean
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30649849#p30649849:3n2cfulg said:Dakke[/url]":3n2cfulg]It's more a teaser than a trailer and it doesn't contain any real new footage or new dialogue. That said, it'll be interesting to see how this season turns out. With the majority of the season being content of the unpublished Winds of Winter, sullied and unsullied alike are now on equal footing.
As for the story itself, I hope Daenarys finally moves from Meereen in the latter end. Three seasons of Slaver's Bay is sufficient. I mostly look forward to the northern and King's Landing plot, though the Ironborn will be quite interesting too. Redemption for Dorne would be welcome. I am most curious about the role of the White Walkers. Hardhome was badass and I hope we see more of their menacing power.
Surely George RR Martin wouldn't kill off everyone's favourite remaining characters? There must be some other explanation. Right?
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30649613#p30649613:2gb5drkx said:trollhunter[/url]":2gb5drkx]A weird thought just passed by my mind.
In any other case I would just shrug it, but it's GoT we are talking about...
What if the planned outcome never was a human victory ? I mean, what if GRRM planned all the time the White Walkers to defeat and convert everything at the end ?
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30649257#p30649257:2ie42xk7 said:mrseb[/url]":2ie42xk7][url=http://arstechnica.co.uk/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30649227#p30649227:2ie42xk7 said:sanloublues[/url]":2ie42xk7]Any major reasons I couldn't or shouldn't switch from the books to the show at this point without watching the previous seasons? Besides all the characters being grownups who don't look like my imagination, I mean
I'm not an expert, but I think there are currently a few questions about how the books will handle the divergence from the TV series. There are quite a few changes in the TV series - and so now, as we move into season six, we have no idea if those changes will be back-propagated to the books. Or if the books will stick to their divergent plot. Or some other solution entirely.
(I haven't read the books - I decided to watch the show first, then read the books later, when/if GRRM finishes them!)
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30651083#p30651083:o0f4q5la said:Frimmel[/url]"0f4q5la]
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30649227#p30649227:o0f4q5la said:sanloublues[/url]"0f4q5la]Any major reasons I couldn't or shouldn't switch from the books to the show at this point without watching the previous seasons? Besides all the characters being grownups who don't look like my imagination, I mean
Others have hit on it but there are some important divergences most particularly with Sansa and Tyrion's journey from King's Landing from the novels. They've also seemed to have excised some plotlines although there is suggestion we'll get those/some of those worked back in with this season. You shouldn't have too much difficulty following along/catching up just jumping into season six.
I watched the first season on a free HBO weekend prior to season three. Went and read the books and then watched the rest of the show. I've enjoyed them both.
I'd recommend getting Season 1 or at least the first episode of season one and giving it a look. You'll have a pretty good idea of what you'd enjoy most from that. (Season 1 is most faithful to the book.)
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30657719#p30657719:2hme9e5l said:azazel1024[/url]":2hme9e5l]I got through book 4 and just couldn't start book 5.
I was enjoying them a lot, but my enjoyment started dying off, not with the characters killed, but with the group ping pong that was happening with points of view.
I can't recall if it was the 3rd or the 4th book that I counted how many points of view there were, but IIRC I hit 17 and I may have missed one or two. That is narrative changes, that is different characters whom the story is told from their point of view.
Sometimes it gets tiring when you hit a cliffhanger of a chapter or something then have to wait 130 pages before the book comes back to that persons narrative to see what is happening and in between you visit 2 other main characters, a secondary character and 2 red shirted ensigns.
Personally it just got to be too much. I enjoyed a lot of the writing and the story telling, but it really did get to be too much jumping around for me and it accelerated as the books went on. I was worried book 5 might not actually have more than 1 chapter dedicated to each character.
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30648737#p30648737:2vn3mftc said:MartinHatch[/url]":2vn3mftc]Jon Snow's fate still in limbo..
No it isn't .. George R Martin already accidentally let slip in an interview that he is alive
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30653437#p30653437:2bg341tq said:Psychophant[/url]":2bg341tq][url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30649849#p30649849:2bg341tq said:Dakke[/url]":2bg341tq]It's more a teaser than a trailer and it doesn't contain any real new footage or new dialogue. That said, it'll be interesting to see how this season turns out. With the majority of the season being content of the unpublished Winds of Winter, sullied and unsullied alike are now on equal footing.
As for the story itself, I hope Daenarys finally moves from Meereen in the latter end. Three seasons of Slaver's Bay is sufficient. I mostly look forward to the northern and King's Landing plot, though the Ironborn will be quite interesting too. Redemption for Dorne would be welcome. I am most curious about the role of the White Walkers. Hardhome was badass and I hope we see more of their menacing power.
Well, she's already out of slaver's bay. The question is now that she is a dragonrider, will she command a Dothraki horde and cross the narrow sea or return to Mereen?
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30661979#p30661979:2wnw5bij said:Dakke[/url]":2wnw5bij][url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30653437#p30653437:2wnw5bij said:Psychophant[/url]":2wnw5bij][url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30649849#p30649849:2wnw5bij said:Dakke[/url]":2wnw5bij]It's more a teaser than a trailer and it doesn't contain any real new footage or new dialogue. That said, it'll be interesting to see how this season turns out. With the majority of the season being content of the unpublished Winds of Winter, sullied and unsullied alike are now on equal footing.
As for the story itself, I hope Daenarys finally moves from Meereen in the latter end. Three seasons of Slaver's Bay is sufficient. I mostly look forward to the northern and King's Landing plot, though the Ironborn will be quite interesting too. Redemption for Dorne would be welcome. I am most curious about the role of the White Walkers. Hardhome was badass and I hope we see more of their menacing power.
Well, she's already out of slaver's bay. The question is now that she is a dragonrider, will she command a Dothraki horde and cross the narrow sea or return to Mereen?
True, that's an important question. I assume she'll bind the Dothraki to her in the Grass Sea and repeal the Yunkese besieging Meereen. Then I think she'll leave (episode 9 or 8), possibly accompanied by Tyrion and Varys, and possibly land in Dorne or the Storm lands (episode 10 or season 7).
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30658339#p30658339:3nyrhqn6 said:jandrese[/url]":3nyrhqn6][url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30657719#p30657719:3nyrhqn6 said:azazel1024[/url]":3nyrhqn6]I got through book 4 and just couldn't start book 5.
I was enjoying them a lot, but my enjoyment started dying off, not with the characters killed, but with the group ping pong that was happening with points of view.
I can't recall if it was the 3rd or the 4th book that I counted how many points of view there were, but IIRC I hit 17 and I may have missed one or two. That is narrative changes, that is different characters whom the story is told from their point of view.
Sometimes it gets tiring when you hit a cliffhanger of a chapter or something then have to wait 130 pages before the book comes back to that persons narrative to see what is happening and in between you visit 2 other main characters, a secondary character and 2 red shirted ensigns.
Personally it just got to be too much. I enjoyed a lot of the writing and the story telling, but it really did get to be too much jumping around for me and it accelerated as the books went on. I was worried book 5 might not actually have more than 1 chapter dedicated to each character.
Can I humbly suggest that you press on and read book five? Book 4 feels almost like GRRM trolling his fanbase by stuffing all of the uninteresting plotlines into a single book and then ending it with a "neener neener all of the good stuff is in book 5!" It's true though, book 5 is a lot better than book 4 (but not as good as 1 or 3 sadly). I really hope the story picks up momentum again in book 6, but with most everybody snowed in (spoiler alert) at the end of book 5 I'm really not sure how it's going to happen.
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30663405#p30663405:1qr85axd said:azazel1024[/url]":1qr85axd][url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30658339#p30658339:1qr85axd said:jandrese[/url]":1qr85axd][url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30657719#p30657719:1qr85axd said:azazel1024[/url]":1qr85axd]I got through book 4 and just couldn't start book 5.
I was enjoying them a lot, but my enjoyment started dying off, not with the characters killed, but with the group ping pong that was happening with points of view.
I can't recall if it was the 3rd or the 4th book that I counted how many points of view there were, but IIRC I hit 17 and I may have missed one or two. That is narrative changes, that is different characters whom the story is told from their point of view.
Sometimes it gets tiring when you hit a cliffhanger of a chapter or something then have to wait 130 pages before the book comes back to that persons narrative to see what is happening and in between you visit 2 other main characters, a secondary character and 2 red shirted ensigns.
Personally it just got to be too much. I enjoyed a lot of the writing and the story telling, but it really did get to be too much jumping around for me and it accelerated as the books went on. I was worried book 5 might not actually have more than 1 chapter dedicated to each character.
Can I humbly suggest that you press on and read book five? Book 4 feels almost like GRRM trolling his fanbase by stuffing all of the uninteresting plotlines into a single book and then ending it with a "neener neener all of the good stuff is in book 5!" It's true though, book 5 is a lot better than book 4 (but not as good as 1 or 3 sadly). I really hope the story picks up momentum again in book 6, but with most everybody snowed in (spoiler alert) at the end of book 5 I'm really not sure how it's going to happen.
Alright, but I am going to hold you accountable!![]()
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30664325#p30664325:2slbv5uy said:Frimmel[/url]":2slbv5uy][url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30663405#p30663405:2slbv5uy said:azazel1024[/url]":2slbv5uy][url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30658339#p30658339:2slbv5uy said:jandrese[/url]":2slbv5uy][url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30657719#p30657719:2slbv5uy said:azazel1024[/url]":2slbv5uy]I got through book 4 and just couldn't start book 5.
I was enjoying them a lot, but my enjoyment started dying off, not with the characters killed, but with the group ping pong that was happening with points of view.
I can't recall if it was the 3rd or the 4th book that I counted how many points of view there were, but IIRC I hit 17 and I may have missed one or two. That is narrative changes, that is different characters whom the story is told from their point of view.
Sometimes it gets tiring when you hit a cliffhanger of a chapter or something then have to wait 130 pages before the book comes back to that persons narrative to see what is happening and in between you visit 2 other main characters, a secondary character and 2 red shirted ensigns.
Personally it just got to be too much. I enjoyed a lot of the writing and the story telling, but it really did get to be too much jumping around for me and it accelerated as the books went on. I was worried book 5 might not actually have more than 1 chapter dedicated to each character.
Can I humbly suggest that you press on and read book five? Book 4 feels almost like GRRM trolling his fanbase by stuffing all of the uninteresting plotlines into a single book and then ending it with a "neener neener all of the good stuff is in book 5!" It's true though, book 5 is a lot better than book 4 (but not as good as 1 or 3 sadly). I really hope the story picks up momentum again in book 6, but with most everybody snowed in (spoiler alert) at the end of book 5 I'm really not sure how it's going to happen.
Alright, but I am going to hold you accountable!![]()
I didn't hate book four but the first half or so really felt like a great big left turn. I get the complaints about it. However book 4.5 (book four and five were originally meant to be one but there was too much) has that whole thing with the Ironborn leading to a showdown I'm quite eager for.
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30658451#p30658451:as4rmzd0 said:Shannara[/url]":as4rmzd0][url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30648737#p30648737:as4rmzd0 said:MartinHatch[/url]":as4rmzd0]Jon Snow's fate still in limbo..
No it isn't .. George R Martin already accidentally let slip in an interview that he is alive
Citation? Where's the link ..
"Yes, I always had plans, what Tyrion's arc was gonna be through this, what Arya's arc was gonna be through this, what Jon Snow's arc is gonna be,"
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30701719#p30701719:22n9tbni said:gulthaw[/url]":22n9tbni][url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30658451#p30658451:22n9tbni said:Shannara[/url]":22n9tbni][url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30648737#p30648737:22n9tbni said:MartinHatch[/url]":22n9tbni]Jon Snow's fate still in limbo..
No it isn't .. George R Martin already accidentally let slip in an interview that he is alive
Citation? Where's the link ..
I was as surprised as you were after reading that, pleasantly though
My google fu didn't fail me so, this is what he said:
"Yes, I always had plans, what Tyrion's arc was gonna be through this, what Arya's arc was gonna be through this, what Jon Snow's arc is gonna be,"
Source
[url=http://arstechnica.co.uk/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30649205#p30649205:3393xufh said:Alyeska[/url]":3393xufh][url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30648751#p30648751:3393xufh said:mrseb[/url]":3393xufh][url=http://arstechnica.co.uk/civis/viewtopic.php?p=30648749#p30648749:3393xufh said:maehara[/url]":3393xufh]Is that a Red Dwarf reference I see in the header? +1 if so.![]()
I like to think that by season eight of GoT, it'll just be Arya Stark wandering around the world - everyone else will have died. Maybe she'll have a pet cat. And a hologram bodyguard.
Don't forget the service mechanoid.