This was actually helpful. I've been in a rut with Dresden - was one of my all time favorite series till it went on it's long hiatus when Butcher had his first divorce and resulting writing crisis. It's been hard to get back in - I still have Peace Talks and Battleground on my Kindle but haven't read them yet. Twelve Months auto-delivered last week when it released (don't even remember pre-ordering), so this review actually gets me motivated to go back a few books and start re-reading.
I can’t blame you for falling off there. The
Peace Talks/
Battle Ground duology had some real issues.
Peace Talks, in particular, I would say is the third weakest book in the entire series behind only
Storm Front and
Fool Moon. But given where Butcher was as a person and author when he wrote those (literally a college kid doing this on his own without an editor, publisher, or really any actual professional help) vs when he wrote PT, relatively speaking the latter is easily his weakest work as an actually established author. PT is rough, no way around it. The surgery to split it into two books was clearly done entirely for the benefit of BG, but after he made that choice he needed to go back and restructure PT both to take advantage of the extra space he now had as well as structure it to work as its own book, and he did neither. The Dresden Files has built up a massive cast of supporting characters over its length, and quite a few so how up in PT for the first time since
Changes. Given everything that’s happened since then you’d think them seeing Harry again would prompt a few conversations, but there’s nothing (in particular for Ivy and Luccio, but for plenty of others also). And the book doesn’t really have its own plot, ultimately serving just as setting the scene for
Battle Ground, without even really attempting an ending.
Battle Ground comes off a lot better (PT took me a week to read; despite being considerably longer I finished BG in 3 days). It’s fast paced, there’s always something happening, and there’s a clear direction and goal to the action. The problem is apart from the opening and closing chapters the entire book is one extended action sequence, and we can only see Harry cast variations of
fuego and
forzare so many times before it starts to wear a bit. Butcher keeps enough variety between the various confrontations that it never becomes entirely stale, but ultimately the breaknececk pace gets fatiguing. It’s still a solid effort, easily placing in the top third of the series, and a welcome bounce back after PT, but not a standout either.
Twelve Months, on the other hand, is a great return to form. The hardest part of it is how personal it feels. It feels inappropriate to armchair analyze a guy I’ve never met, and everyone’s entitled to their privacy, but Butcher has been open that he’s had a rough go of it in his own personal life over the last decade or so (there’s a reason the book releases slowed to a crawl), and in this book at times it’s hard to tell where Harry’s own internal monologue ends and Butcher’s begins in this one. On the flip side he’s become a good enough author that even if he is working out his own issues on the page in front of the entire world, it’s pretty compelling and makes this by
far the most human book in the entire series.