How Tesla Takedown got its start

Post content hidden for low score. Show…
Post content hidden for low score. Show…

nancy-drew

Ars Centurion
357
Subscriptor++
Just incredible how Musk has managed to alienate almost every demographic in just a few short years.
The left grew disillusioned with him when he started going full-fascist around 2023, turning to full hate after the Trump endorsement. Now the right hates him too (he impugned the Great Pumpkin!)

This is a great position for a high-profile, personality-selling businessman.

EDIT: Yes, I'm aware he was an asshole long before 2023. He leaked fascist thoughts when he was too high to stop himself starting a long time ago
 
Last edited:
Upvote
167 (173 / -6)

markus

Smack-Fu Master, in training
65
It's a shame, what a mess. Tesla was The American EV company and an important part of electrifying transportation and fighting climate change, but Musk crossed the Rubicon into politics, poisoned his brand, and he can't take that back. We're worse off now. We have so many problems to face and lots and lots of flawed solutions and tools. At this point I'm hoping for activist investors to push him out and maybe something worthwhile can be made of Tesla - but the shine is gone regardless.
 
Upvote
98 (103 / -5)
Post content hidden for low score. Show…
By the time Musk appeared onstage at a rally following Trump’s inauguration in January 2025 and threw out what appeared to be a Nazi salute

It did not "appear" as anything. That was a Nazi salute. He can deny all he wants to. But you don't throw that out as a joke.

Fuck Elon.
 
Upvote
210 (223 / -13)
Post content hidden for low score. Show…

squid_whisperer

Ars Centurion
226
Subscriptor++
It is and was just a shitty car, but had a novel approach. Car makers thought they could have sale numbers like Tesla as well (dah…no you can’t).

Now everybody is making (better) electric cars and people are fed up with the poor quality of Teslas and their overselling and underdelivering of features.

I don’t think it has much to do with Musk. I couldn’t care less what the CEO of Mercedes or BMW does, I care for price/performance.
I think it has a huge amount to do with the negative press he constantly generates. Most of my peer group, who are the sort of people who might have bought a Tesla, won't do it now.
 
Upvote
87 (88 / -1)

lasertekk

Ars Scholae Palatinae
1,470
The left grew disillusioned with him when he started going full-fascist around 2023, turning to full hate after the Trump endorsement. Now the right hates him too (he impugned the Great Pumpkin!)

This is a great position for a high-profile, personality-selling businessman
Check your calendar. When Covid restrictions kicked in during early 2020, those first many months when hospitals were inundated, bodies were filling up morgues and we still weren’t quite sure how to deal with it to reduce casualties, Mr Musk refused a health order by California state gov to shut down his Fremont plant. This is when he decided to build a plant in Texas (July), which didn’t care if people died. Timing is also important. This is when he needed to pass a certain performance threshold, to get that first huge payout of several billion dollars, remember that? That’s when he changed. The greed got to him. It was overnight. He went ‘right’ in the second half of 2020.
 
Upvote
122 (124 / -2)
Just incredible how Musk has managed to alienate almost every demographic in just a few short years.
I've said before that Musk was the perfect CEO to run a startup in the auto and space industries. He's bad at mature companies. I've wanted him out as CEO of Tesla since he did the "no lidar! no IR sensors! just cameras and ai!" bit.

As a liberal, before 2020 he was a minimally acceptable billionaire. He actually risked his own money to invest in high-risk, high-payoff projects like EVs and cheap rockets like the Objectivists say all rich people do. (No, he wouldn't have been bankrupt if SpaceX had failed, but he's be stuck at hundred-millionaire poor boy). I could mostly ignore his politics as long as he was just another glibertarian blowhard. Then he went down the radicalization pipeline to Qanon.

One thing few people noticed was that the Christian Nationalists started hating him almost immediately after the inauguration. Musk was gleefully doing everything on the oligarch's checklist, but the Christian Nationalists were getting very little of what they thought Trump had promised them. Just in random doomscrolling I came across two different CN influencers who were matching Musk to the prophecies of Revelations.
 
Upvote
66 (69 / -3)

ranthog

Ars Legatus Legionis
15,319
Check your calendar. When Covid restrictions kicked in during early 2020, those first many months when hospitals were inundated, bodies were filling up morgues and we still weren’t quite sure how to deal with it to reduce casualties, Mr Musk refused a health order by California state gov to shut down his Fremont plant. This is when he decided to build a plant in Texas (July), which didn’t care if people died. Timing is also important. This is when he needed to pass a certain performance threshold, to get that first huge payout of several billion dollars, remember that? That’s when he changed. The greed got to him. It was overnight. He went ‘right’ in the second half of 2020.
I don't see any signs that Musk himself changed. Especially given his creepy as fuck behavior towards women and active discrimination problems at his facilities.

The thing that changed is that he completely stopped managing his own image of being a savior figure like Tony Stark.
 
Upvote
61 (63 / -2)
Post content hidden for low score. Show…

pemmet

Wise, Aged Ars Veteran
199
I'm glad I'm too much of a pussy to short Tesla because it is fucking remarkable how well they prove that the market can remain irrational longer than I can stay solvent.

This is wisdom for the ages- Thank you for reminding me why i need to be careful if i ever get money*.


*Currently being a pussy isn't my problem; my current malady is 'broke-ass-bitch', but I'm saving & paying down debt!
 
Upvote
46 (46 / 0)

Snark218

Ars Legatus Legionis
36,749
Subscriptor
It is and was just a shitty car, but had a novel approach. Car makers thought they could have sale numbers like Tesla as well (dah…no you can’t).

Now everybody is making (better) electric cars and people are fed up with the poor quality of Teslas and their overselling and underdelivering of features.

I don’t think it has much to do with Musk. I couldn’t care less what the CEO of Mercedes or BMW does, I care for price/performance.
You may be indifferent and you can speak for yourself, but I think that perspective leads you to underrate not just how much people dislike Musk but also the company's long-standing hostility to protections for workers, investors, air and water quality, minorities, safety, and the communities they operate in.
 
Upvote
69 (71 / -2)

Snark218

Ars Legatus Legionis
36,749
Subscriptor
I don't see any signs that Musk himself changed. Especially given his creepy as fuck behavior towards women and active discrimination problems at his facilities.

The thing that changed is that he completely stopped managing his own image of being a savior figure like Tony Stark.
Yeah. His degree of self-control and accountability changed, the number of people around him willing to rein him in changed, but he's still who he always was. Maybe some of his failure modes got amplified by taking what sounds like all the drugs, but even that's a matter of degree.
 
Upvote
61 (62 / -1)
Post content hidden for low score. Show…
Post content hidden for low score. Show…
Post content hidden for low score. Show…

Bob Dobilina

Ars Scholae Palatinae
866
It would be better if it was short (and not short because the movement ran out of steam).
The movement may have run out of steam but it did make the Tesla brand toxic to many people, caused enough chaos to force Musk out of DC earlier than intended (yeah, DOGE is still screwing things up and most of the damage is done) and IMO fueled the inevitable breakup between Trump & Musk.

What drives me nuts is that a couple random tweets lead to a focused demonstration that for the first time caused an actual disruption in the administration’s agenda. Meanwhile, despite their vast resources, the Democratic Party has done nothing. The Dems need to build a propaganda machine.
 
Upvote
33 (34 / -1)
Post content hidden for low score. Show…

ranthog

Ars Legatus Legionis
15,319
While the takedown movement have a right to protest, I would like to remind folks that there are real people with families that are working at Tesla and attacking them or setting fire to a service center is not the right approach

Neither is threatening folks who drive a car that they have bought in the past and may be unable to sell due to depreciation/financial reasons and are simply trying to get to work or take their kids to school
The problem is you're focusing on the exceptions rather than the rule. There is no need to remind people when 99.9999% of what is going on is perfectly nonviolent. It makes you as bad as Trump talking about how LA is burning down.

Ironically, the one who did the most damage to Tesla drivers in this case is Musk and Trump calling this terrorism. That is exactly the excuse insurance needs to not pay to fix the cars if they got keyed or spray-painted.
 
Upvote
73 (73 / 0)

justsomebytes

Wise, Aged Ars Veteran
191
Subscriptor
I'm hoping we can agree that nationalizing ANYTHING is never the answer, no matter how temporal the intent may be.
Not just nationalizing, having the government run anything is bad. We know everything would have consumers best interests if it were run by private interests. If anything we should turn the government over to Elon to privatize everything!

Oh wait .....
/s (just to be clear)
 
Upvote
26 (31 / -5)
D

Deleted member 221201

Guest
The movement may have run out of steam but it did make the Tesla brand toxic to many people, caused enough chaos to force Musk out of DC earlier than intended (yeah, DOGE is still screwing things up and most of the damage is done) and IMO fueled the inevitable breakup between Trump & Musk.

What drives me nuts is that a couple random tweets lead to a focused demonstration that for the first time caused an actual disruption in the administration’s agenda. Meanwhile, despite their vast resources, the Democratic Party has done nothing. The Dems need to build a propaganda machine.
The judiciary needs to grow a pair and have checks and balances
 
Upvote
19 (21 / -2)

Snark218

Ars Legatus Legionis
36,749
Subscriptor
While the takedown movement have a right to protest, I would like to remind folks that there are real people with families that are working at Tesla and attacking them or setting fire to a service center is not the right approach

Neither is threatening folks who drive a car that they have bought in the past and may be unable to sell due to depreciation/financial reasons and are simply trying to get to work or take their kids to school
That kind of common sense thinking doesn't fly in the Tesla comment section here. It's more like the Two Minutes of Hate.

Doesn't matter who else they hurt, as long as they get the one they hate ...
I'm a federal employee. Were either of you sanctimoniously wringing your hands for me when Elon was threatening my livelihood and that of hundreds of thousands of my colleagues? Bet fucking not.

Tesla is a shit company, and Tesla's success directly enriches Elon. Elon is a fascist piece of shit who has done incalculable damage to the effectiveness of the federal government, to basic and applied research, to American soft power, and to the rule of law in this country. Tesla has violated every regulatory protection I can think of for investors, workers, air and water quality, and their own customers. I don't particularly wish ill on Tesla employees and their families, at least the ones not directly complicit in enabling Elon. Mortgage ain't gonna pay itself. For whatever it's worth, I hope they move on before the house of cards collapses. The ones who are complicit, fuck them, and the same goes for those who rhetorically carry water for them by disingenuously appealing to my fucking compassion.
 
Upvote
151 (153 / -2)

red_shift_limited

Ars Centurion
222
Subscriptor
Musk has done a wonderful job of disproving the 'great man' theory of history. He's been successful despite his actions and personality which shows that the people around him are working 1000% harder than he does.

People STILL telling me that he's actually a genius or that he had some great ideas and lost his way are on my side-eye list. He's just another sociopath from a rich family that failed upward. Yes he chose some companies that do things that we like but he wasn't the secret sauce there.

I've been to my local Tesla protest, it's pretty chill except for some angry Tesla owners that feel personally insulted for some reason. We don't mind that you bought the car but please stop supporting the owner.
 
Upvote
73 (75 / -2)