Hands on with the triangular Nanoleaf Aurora smart lighting system

Status
Not open for further replies.

wireframed

Ars Legatus Legionis
17,288
Subscriptor
I think what I'm really waiting for is more API integration with mail clients, Twitter, Facebook, et al. Though I'm sure we don't need another means of notification around the house.
Philips Hue lets you control lights through a simple API with JSON. They even have an API to build the requests you need to send.

If you can hack together something to run a query, you can make them react to it - very simple.

Also, they use Zigby protocol so other products can integrate. (Like Osrams plugs)
 
Upvote
15 (15 / 0)

neodorian

Ars Tribunus Militum
1,985
Now I wish I had a 3d printer so I could build something like this. It's relatively easy with Arduino-style microcontrollers, RGB LEDs, and some of the tools out there for controlling via mobile apps but building a solid diffuser like that would probably look much less halfassed if I could print the parts from plastic rather than rigging something up from tinkertoys and felt ;)
 
Upvote
-1 (4 / -5)

Bicentennial Douche

Ars Legatus Legionis
10,345
Subscriptor
Would make a neat, rich man's Ambilight system to put around your TV. Just missing the sensor.

Uh, not really. I mean, the sensor is the entire point of Ambilight. If the lights don't change color, then there is no point.

In case people don't know what Ambilight is: it's LEDs in back of certain Philips-TV's, that change color to match what's being displayed on the screen:

ambilight-feature-image.jpg
 
Upvote
25 (25 / 0)
My Feit 60w equivalent LED lights are rated at 800lm/9w so these panels (900lm/18w) are roughly half as efficient as mainstream LED lighting. I don't believe that these are intended to be a primary lighting source though so comparison is not really apropos. A better comparison might be with Philips Hue, where the Aurora is actually about as efficient.

Hue 9w bulb rated output:
360 lm @ 2000K
510 lm @ 3000K
550 lm @ 6500K
600 lm @ 4000K
 
Upvote
12 (12 / 0)

Sidorian

Seniorius Lurkius
8
I've been using these since December and everyone that has walked through my foyer is enamored by them. App is pretty simple to use, and haven't run into many issues yet. The mounting does kind of suck, especially now that they include those foam adhesives rather than Command Strips, which were in the earlier kits. I tried to use poster mounting puddy and it worked for a few weeks until I heard a couple tiles crash in the middle of the night. Luckily I can attest that they did not break from a couple feet.

Overall they are great, and if you think of them as an art installation, the price is reasonable. As an everyday source of light? Yeah, pretty pricey.

FYI, Frys.com has them routinely on sale for $150 when signing up for their email. That's how I got my second kit because more tiles the merrier!
 
Upvote
16 (16 / 0)

Morley Dotes

Ars Scholae Palatinae
761
I've been using these since December and everyone that has walked through my foyer is enamored by them. App is pretty simple to use, and haven't run into many issues yet. The mounting does kind of suck, especially now that they include those foam adhesives rather than Command Strips, which were in the earlier kits. I tried to use poster mounting puddy and it worked for a few weeks until I heard a couple tiles crash in the middle of the night. Luckily I can attest that they did not break from a couple feet.

Overall they are great, and if you think of them as an art installation, the price is reasonable. As an everyday source of light? Yeah, pretty pricey.

FYI, Frys.com has them routinely on sale for $150 when signing up for their email. That's how I got my second kit because more tiles the merrier!

Thanks for the info.

Does the app/unit require Internet connectivity?
 
Upvote
4 (4 / 0)
Post content hidden for low score. Show…
I think what I'm really waiting for is more API integration with mail clients, Twitter, Facebook, et al. Though I'm sure we don't need another means of notification around the house.
That is already a solved problem.

http://lifehacker.com/the-best-gmail-if ... -576181920

Since you do not know, IfThisThenThat or IFTTT is an IOT integration service that lets you combine simple recipes for various services to do truly random things with your supported devices and services.
 
Upvote
1 (1 / 0)

jdale

Ars Legatus Legionis
18,433
Subscriptor
I think what I'm really waiting for is more API integration with mail clients, Twitter, Facebook, et al. Though I'm sure we don't need another means of notification around the house.

I have some Insteon-connected colored lights that indicate the status of the motion sensors on the porch and whether the laundry is running. It's actually pretty convenient, easy to see yet subtle, looks more like an art piece than a notification. Have been meaning to set up some more.

I also like the look of the Aurora.

But there's no excuse for making it dependent on Android and/or iOS and requiring an internet connection. It's wifi, you should also be able to control it from a PC, laptop, etc.
 
Upvote
4 (4 / 0)

Erorus

Ars Tribunus Angusticlavius
6,674
Subscriptor
The author should have included a video of his unit in action.

It's a lighting system, and the author includes two pictures of it turned on (in one configuration), and four pictures of it in pieces.

When even the story title contains the word "art", perhaps we should have more "show," and less "tell."
 
Upvote
5 (5 / 0)
This looks pretty cool and I'd like to have one. However, I just came from the article about the creepy IoT bear so I'm curious about this device from a security perspective. What information did it ask for when you installed the app? Are all of your settings saved on the Aurora or on a server somewhere? What, if any, information does Nanoleaf collect about your network and where does it send it? Can the Aurora be updated over the network?

I looked at the Nanoleaf website but I didn't see any security information.
 
Upvote
5 (5 / 0)

Terry Dunn

Seniorius Lurkius
5
Wow...lots of comments so far. I'll try to address the pending questions.

I can't intelligently comment on the security of the system, but it does seem that they do not require real-time internet connectivity. I just disconnected my home network and cell phone from the internet. I was able to connect to and control the Aurora through the app.

Yes, the app has a scheduling feature to turn on/off and set certain effects at selected times.

That was a good idea about posting a video. I just stuck a RunCam2 on a tripod in front of the lights and worked through a few transitions. The cam makes the light seem harsher than it really is, but you get some idea of how it works.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SNYw0FgkMgY

When set to white light and full brightness (or near), I think this set "could" be used as primary lighting for a moderately-sized room. However, I think the bigger issue would be placement rather than brightness. Coming from a wall instead of the ceiling creates weird shadows and dead spots if there are no other light sources. Kinda like using a desk lamp to light a room. Just my opinion.

Any other pressing questions?

Terry
 
Upvote
27 (27 / 0)

adespoton

Ars Legatus Legionis
10,778
Terry, I just thought I'd point out that what you called "masking tape" is technically painter's tape (frog tape). It can prevent paint seepage much better than masking tape and is easier to remove.

Thanks for the excellent review! I can't believe anyone would ever recommend using double sided foam tape on anything that might get dislodged or have a life expectancy of more than 5 years (both surfaces). I'm wary enough about command strips.
 
Upvote
4 (4 / 0)

lewax00

Ars Legatus Legionis
17,402
Now I wish I had a 3d printer so I could build something like this. It's relatively easy with Arduino-style microcontrollers, RGB LEDs, and some of the tools out there for controlling via mobile apps but building a solid diffuser like that would probably look much less halfassed if I could print the parts from plastic rather than rigging something up from tinkertoys and felt ;)
You'd be better off just buying sheets of diffusing plastic rather than trying to print something. A 3D print wouldn't come out smooth enough (neither on the surface nor internally) to look good as a diffuser.

Hmm, I have hue for much of my apt, but have some dark areas these would be nice. But big question for me is how easy it integrated into amazon echo system. Being able to tell alexa to turn on / off lights is huge for me.
Their site says it works with Alexa. No Google Home though...(at least, I think, their page didn't entirely load for me).
 
Upvote
4 (4 / 0)

Terry Dunn

Seniorius Lurkius
5
Terry, I just thought I'd point out that what you called "masking tape" is technically painter's tape (frog tape). It can prevent paint seepage much better than masking tape and is easier to remove.
I'm with you. I just used generic terminology to keep things simple. Frog Tape is my go to when actually painting things...for the reasons you mentioned.
 
Upvote
3 (3 / 0)

lewax00

Ars Legatus Legionis
17,402
Terry, I just thought I'd point out that what you called "masking tape" is technically painter's tape (frog tape). It can prevent paint seepage much better than masking tape and is easier to remove.

Thanks for the excellent review! I can't believe anyone would ever recommend using double sided foam tape on anything that might get dislodged or have a life expectancy of more than 5 years (both surfaces). I'm wary enough about command strips.
Technically, painter's tape is a kind of masking tape. And masking tape was invented for use in painting...it's literally tape used to mask the surface you don't want to paint.
 
Upvote
10 (10 / 0)
Status
Not open for further replies.