Apple MacBook Neo review: Can a Mac get by with an iPhone’s processor inside?

Status
You're currently viewing only reyan's posts. Click here to go back to viewing the entire thread.
The review is nicely written for the Ars audience, but the Ars audience has only the scantest overlap with the Neo’s intended market.

I predict that Apple will sell boatloads of the Neo, mostly to users who don’t need to know or care about external 4K monitors or editing RAW images.
That’s what I thought. What the reviewer called “normal use” is…. Not normal for people who buy these cheap laptops.

As soon as he mentioned editing RAW photos or using Audacity, he moved outside the target market.

I suspect the use cases listed are beyond what most MacBook Air users do, let alone the target market for the Neo.

I was personally hoping to see more performance from the A18 pro, I assumed it wouldn’t be throttled like it is in a phone. But when I think of my Mom (on an M2 Air 8GB) who actually has standard use cases for the Neo target market, I doubt she would notice a difference (performance wise… she uses a lot of I/O so would notice the port downgrade).

ETA: I have a Mac Studio 32GB for any heavy work, so I think what I do on my M1 Air 8GB is more in-line with a standard Neo targeted user. I’ve never felt limited on the Air, despite having dozens of tabs open between Chrome and Safari.
 
Last edited:
Upvote
8 (8 / 0)
It's becoming difficult to see how this is a better replacement for the Walmart M1 Air, other than being more widely available and in colors. It has the same price but worse performance, worse battery life, less resolution screen, worse ports, worse trackpad, etc.
Generally agreed, but I would counter with: Longer support period.
 
Upvote
4 (4 / 0)
Oh yeah, sorry can't say on running Linux on this one (or any Snapdragon). I thought Linux had okay ARM support for some reason. This is a little bit more expensive at $750, but seems solid for what you are looking for.

https://www.bestbuy.com/product/hp-...ry1-tb-ssd-glacier-silver-aluminum/JJGH2LFK84
Linux has excellent ARM support. Apple silicon uses the ARM instruction set for the CPU, but ARM support doesn’t mean Linux will automatically support the custom GPU, custom NPU, all of the hardware such as the trackpad, Wifi, etc etc.

Standard Linux on ARM is much more of a server and embedded market thing (and raspberry pi of course).

ETA: Ditto for snapdragon x machines. same issue, the ARM instruction set is not the roadblock.
 
Upvote
11 (11 / 0)
Status
You're currently viewing only reyan's posts. Click here to go back to viewing the entire thread.