I PERSONALLY swipe up from the bottom and it ignores me 70% of the time. I swipe up 1-3x more and if I didn't swipe far enough, it takes me to the app switcher or the Dock.
For those of you who are not good at reading comprehension, I want to emphasise this is my personal everyday experience and what happens with your fingers on your devices has NO BEARING on what happens to me.
I have twenty-seven apps that I use every day on my iPad Air, which means I have to suffer with the unreliable app switching at least thirty times a day.
As you can imagine, I LOATHE using my iPad Air and have publicly vocalised here that the experience is so horrid that even though I am currently running five iPads at the same time (plus two computers), once the iPads die, I will be without any mobile devices because having no Home button is just that much of a hinderance for me.
It looks fantastic, but just as if someone produced an automobile with the doors intentionally welded shut, it's a usability hassle for those of us who are just unable to leap through the window thirty+ times a day.
To endear itself to me even further, there is a 40% chance that swiping to switch apps will then rotate the screen 90º. This happens even on my Home button-equipped iPads so I suppose I'm just "not swiping correctly."
After doing this 30x a day for 3.5 years, that's 38,325 times I've had to deal with app switching failing on me. If I was ever going to become acclimated to it, I imagine it would have happened by now. In that same time frame, the Home buttons on all of my other iPads have worked with roughly 100% accuracy.
As a reminder, this post is all about my 38,325 poor experiences and not anyone else's.
Perhaps most people don't have twenty-seven daily apps and don't mind swiping being hopelessly unreliable but I am often in a rush and there's nothing more enjoyable than dealing with balky gestures which were hastily tacked on because some executive thought iPad would "look cool" if it had no Home button.
There are also the issues that: 1) Since iPad Air is a virtually featureless slab, I somehow manage to pick it up wrong 75% of the time. I go to press the volume button and it's on the other side and I have to carefully rotate the (as Apple calls it) "sheet of glass" 180º or my thumb is over the camera or if I have the TouchID active, then I have to hunt around the edge for the Top button. Not to mention that while many apps are orientation-less, some popular well-maintained apps such as the hit app Animal Crossing: Pocket Camp will only work in ONE orientation so there is only one way you can hold iPad, which is easy to do if you have the visual indication that a Home button offers. 2) Since there's no headphone jack, I must use a USB-C adapter because virtually no one makes over-ear noise cancelling headphones these days and in my experience, BT introduces a lag. This means I can't use headphones and charge simultaneously (maybe there's a third party adapter which I don't have but still, we didn't need to spend MORE money for this functionality before) and the adapter has a tendency to fall out. If a proper headphone plug falls out of a jack, you can push it back in and it'll work immediately. On the other hand, a USB-C to headphone jack adapter has a significant delay between when you insert it and when you can hear so this, as with Top button TouchID, is a clumsy replacement.
I do wish some company would make computing devices for the rest of us.
Edit: Since Apple removed the Home button, in order to get Home, they added the Home bar to the "bottom" of the screen. This is a translucent line that sometimes disappears but is usually visible.
If you take a screen shot, most of the time, the Home bar is branded onto your image. That makes me ever so thrilled they removed the Home button.
Also, there are times when iPadOS gets confused and thinks down is somewhere not down. (This just happened to me yet again with the latest iPadOS 17 version, hence this edit.) So, it'll draw the Home bar on one of the sides but when you try to swipe the Home bar, nothing happens. So you must test the other sides until you find where down really is.
Fantastic.