Twitter suspended journalist for reporting on Matt Walsh’s hacked materials

Aurich

Director of Many Things
40,906
Ars Staff
Matt Walsh is a shitty human being, so of course I find all this funny and I'm rooting against him. But even if this reporter wasn't with Wired I'm always going to be on the side of journalists being able to cover stories like this. Public figure getting hacked is a news story. Confirming that the hack really happened and discussing the details without revealing things that could put someone in danger etc is reasonable.
 
Upvote
514 (544 / -30)

Fatesrider

Ars Legatus Legionis
24,979
Subscriptor
Based on the descriptions of what constitutes bannable behavior on Twitter, this sounds like it was an executive decision (and we know who made it) because the nuances of policy could have gone either way, and Musk got angry, again, over one of his Reich-wing buddies being outed and humiliated on Twitter.

Love how Musk is all about "free speech" as long as it's some fucking fascist doing the speaking...
 
Upvote
458 (485 / -27)
Post content hidden for low score. Show…

rcduke

Ars Tribunus Militum
2,172
Subscriptor++
On Thursday afternoon, Wired editor-in-chief Gideon Lichfield tweeted that Twitter told Cameron that he "had broken its rules by “directly distribut[ing] content obtained through hacking that contains private information, may put people in physical harm or danger, or contains trade secrets.”
(Emphasis mine)

I get why this rule is in place. Distribution of hacked materials could effective doxx someone's location, employment (if not public) and overall cause issues. Yet Twitter is allowing transphobic comments to be posted on their site which could effectively lead to the target being harmed.

I suspect that since Walsh is on the "conservative" side of things and this hack showed the fragility of Twitter's infrastructure that Musk ordered this journalist's account banned. The ban being issued to "prove a point that we will not allow statements in poor taste" negates Musk's free speech argument but we all know that was a lie anyway.
 
Upvote
182 (199 / -17)

Aurich

Director of Many Things
40,906
Ars Staff
I suspect that since Walsh is on the "conservative" side of things and this hack showed the fragility of Twitter's infrastructure that Musk ordered this journalist's account banned.
And yet, we wouldn't cover "Crummy wannabe provocateur gets account hacked" as a story by itself. As always the attempt to cover things up is the bigger story.
 
Upvote
196 (203 / -7)
Matt Walsh is a shitty human being, so of course I find all this funny and I'm rooting against him. But even if this reporter wasn't with Wired I'm always going to be on the side of journalists being able to cover stories like this. Public figure getting hacked is a news story. Confirming that the hack really happened and discussing the details without revealing things that could put someone in danger etc is reasonable.
That's the nicest thing I've ever seen someone say about Matt Walsh.
 
Upvote
118 (132 / -14)

PhilGil

Ars Scholae Palatinae
1,347
Twitter’s hacked materials policy was last updated in October 2020, after the scandal where the platform blocked a New York Post article reporting on Hunter Biden’s hacked laptop.
scandal <> Twitter (and the US media) fact-checking a dubious story broken by a Murdoch-owned tabloid during "October surprise" month in a presidential election year. The only scandal is in the minds of right-wing nutjobs who are still trying to turn Hunter Biden's laptop into Joe Biden's Benghazi.
 
Upvote
73 (88 / -15)
Post content hidden for low score. Show…
Post content hidden for low score. Show…

Urist

Ars Praefectus
4,328
Subscriptor
So celebrities getting their accounts hacked and they start claiming they're going to give out iPads? For days? Good luck getting Twitter to help you!

A virulent transphobe gets hacked? Twitter's on it ASAP!

Musk's priorities (which we knew were all garbage, but...)

Elon: Freeze Peach must be absolute! Which is why are allowing targeted harassment of trans people on our platform.

Also Elon: Information wants to be free! which is why we are endlessly hyping up the Twitter Files Biden laptop bullshit.

Also Also Elon: I will personally ban anyone who leaks my bestie Matt Walsh's dirty secrets!
 
Upvote
154 (165 / -11)
Based on the descriptions of what constitutes bannable behavior on Twitter, this sounds like it was an executive decision (and we know who made it) because the nuances of policy could have gone either way, and Musk got angry, again, over one of his Reich-wing buddies being outed and humiliated on Twitter.

Love how Musk is all about "free speech" as long as it's some fucking fascist doing the speaking...
I'm more concerned with the chilling effects on free speech when Entitled Rich White Guy threatens you with a lawsuit from very expensive lawyers, way better than you can afford, than I am about some counterfactual hypothesizing about Dick Move Elon Did This Week #7. Elon being an moron, I would argue, is barely newsworthy any more, and should just be expected.
 
Upvote
45 (49 / -4)

willyu34

Ars Scholae Palatinae
1,415
Wouldn’t be surprised if musk personally ordered lackeys to do the suspension. After all conservative leader Poilievre got musk to label CBC recently.

Honestly, never thought I would use this image so soon again, the second time, on the same day only few hours apart. I guess this got old really fast with such frequent usage.
(Thanks Aurich and CraigJ for this terrible gift to the world lol)

Edit: I removed the pic… it got old fast and i think we are probably tired of it.
 
Last edited:
Upvote
3 (13 / -10)
I don't know who any of the people in this story are, but I found this bit interesting. Did someone clone this guy's cell phone? How did all MFA get bypassed?

I would RTFA, but the Wired article is paywalled.
The Ars coverage:
In the Wired report, Cameron reveals how Walsh’s account was hacked. Doomed confirmed he used a technique called SIM swapping, relying on an “insider” close to Walsh, who helped Doomed trick a cellular provider into switching the SIM card associated with Walsh’s account to a SIM card that Doomed controlled. Cameron’s reporting thus confirmed a tweet from Walsh suggesting that an “insider” helped the hacker.
 
Upvote
63 (64 / -1)
I totally agree with Elon Musk's position here; journalists shouldn't be able to report that figures on the far right have been hacked. No, I choose to believe Matt Walsh really did say all those things his account posted during that time period. Who are you, or anyone else to tell me that I need to know anything deeper? This can only ever work out wonderfully, thanks to the wise Mr Musk. And those postings were no more insane than the rest of Walsh's theocratic-fascist postings anyway. Totally believable it was him all along, he'd never make a mistake or be victim of anyone else's actions...

It is thus factually true that Matt Walsh is a "Sassy Shoota", and that he thinks Joe Rogan is a paedophile.
 
Upvote
54 (60 / -6)

Wheels Of Confusion

Ars Legatus Legionis
75,414
Subscriptor
Musk's Twitter doing exactly the same thing they accused the previous Twitter owners of doing?
Man, it's almost as if his "unfettered free speech, public square, anything not illegal is allowed, no more censorship" jibba-jabba was just a lie that only stupid people (possibly including himself) believed.

It turns out, Musk really just loves banning journalists and picking fights with "liberal" news organizations at the behest of right-wing trolls who play him like a fiddle.
 
Upvote
136 (138 / -2)

Wheels Of Confusion

Ars Legatus Legionis
75,414
Subscriptor
I hope that The Daily Wire and Wet Malsh spend a ton of money on lawsuits and get absolutely nothing, and better yet end up paying the legal fees for the defendants.
Frankly I hope they're all talk. Nobody needs to be subjected to an expensive and time-consuming frivolous lawsuit in the American system.
 
Upvote
46 (48 / -2)

Maxipad

Ars Tribunus Militum
2,738
Based on the descriptions of what constitutes bannable behavior on Twitter, this sounds like it was an executive decision (and we know who made it) because the nuances of policy could have gone either way, and Musk got angry, again, over one of his Reich-wing buddies being outed and humiliated on Twitter.

Love how Musk is all about "free speech" as long as it's some fucking fascist doing the speaking...
And Musk is the guy who hired a private detective to try to prove someone was a pedophile (they weren't).

And he's banning a reporter for reporting on a hack (of one of his buddies)? I guess hypocrisy IS on brand for Elon.

What a turd.
 
Upvote
65 (69 / -4)

david newall

Ars Scholae Palatinae
1,168
Is this really about Matt Walsh being hacked, or are Twitter truly annoyed by reporting of a Twitter account being hacked? Neither should put someone out of the Twattersphere, but I can see His Muskiness getting cranky over either one of those. And maybe anything that makes Twizzle look a little insecure might annoy him more.
 
Upvote
19 (23 / -4)