Google announces the new Chromecast

Status
Not open for further replies.
Post content hidden for low score. Show…

Damnicus

Ars Scholae Palatinae
637
Subscriptor++
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=29841049#p29841049:28wp4vjh said:
DrDenim[/url]":28wp4vjh]I only remember reading inital reviews of the chromecast saying it was pretty garbage. Laggy, lacking features and pretty useless. Did it ever get better? Does it work with my wife's iphone? Having to navigate with my phone kinda sounds like a pain (waiting for apps etc)

Yes, yes, and not really.
 
Upvote
58 (58 / 0)

Kilroy420

Ars Tribunus Militum
2,038
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=29841049#p29841049:2pr5h7ne said:
DrDenim[/url]":2pr5h7ne]I only remember reading inital reviews of the chromecast saying it was pretty garbage. Laggy, lacking features and pretty useless. Did it ever get better? Does it work with my wife's iphone? Having to navigate with my phone kinda sounds like a pain (waiting for apps etc)

I never had an problems with the original Chromecast. Even using it on business travel to plug into the HDTVs in the hotel rooms to ride off my phone's WiFi hot spot was painless.

All in all, it was a great device for $35

I hope they manage to keep the low price point. The originals made good stocking stuffers for Christmas too.
 
Upvote
26 (27 / -1)
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=29841049#p29841049:2yq0sr1x said:
DrDenim[/url]":2yq0sr1x]I only remember reading inital reviews of the chromecast saying it was pretty garbage. Laggy, lacking features and pretty useless. Did it ever get better? Does it work with my wife's iphone? Having to navigate with my phone kinda sounds like a pain (waiting for apps etc)
I was generally happy with it with my iPhone and desktop. Other than faster network speeds, the other thing I would have liked was ad hoc networking for when I travel. Until it collapsed, it was the feature I was most excited for with Matchstick.
 
Upvote
4 (4 / 0)
The moment you open the Netflix app, Netflix detects you have a Chromecast and pre-loads the app on the TV

I hope this doesn't mean the Chromecast switches inputs automatically. We had a problem with that on my wife's Kindle. I'd be playing PS3 or whatever, and she'd fire up Netflix on her Kindle - and it would engage the Chromecast, which would switch inputs on the TV. It got annoying very quickly.

e: To be clear, I want Chromecast to switch inputs - when I want to cast. I just don't want it to switch inputs when I want to watch something on my phone or tablet. Adjusting the settings on the TV would block both.

The behavior stopped on the Kindle Netflix app, so maybe they have it figured out. Hopefully.
 
Upvote
16 (18 / -2)

Oletros

Ars Tribunus Militum
2,238
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=29841049#p29841049:6dbfr12f said:
DrDenim[/url]":6dbfr12f]I only remember reading inital reviews of the chromecast saying it was pretty garbage. Laggy, lacking features and pretty useless. Did it ever get better? Does it work with my wife's iphone? Having to navigate with my phone kinda sounds like a pain (waiting for apps etc)

Reviews on Appleinsider?
 
Upvote
61 (64 / -3)

DrDenim

Ars Scholae Palatinae
617
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=29841093#p29841093:21y947da said:
Oletros[/url]":21y947da]
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=29841049#p29841049:21y947da said:
DrDenim[/url]":21y947da]I only remember reading inital reviews of the chromecast saying it was pretty garbage. Laggy, lacking features and pretty useless. Did it ever get better? Does it work with my wife's iphone? Having to navigate with my phone kinda sounds like a pain (waiting for apps etc)

Reviews on Appleinsider?

Lol, close. The Verge I think..
 
Upvote
1 (17 / -16)

TomXP411

Ars Tribunus Angusticlavius
9,356
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=29841049#p29841049:3jkj4zvb said:
DrDenim[/url]":3jkj4zvb]I only remember reading inital reviews of the chromecast saying it was pretty garbage. Laggy, lacking features and pretty useless. Did it ever get better? Does it work with my wife's iphone? Having to navigate with my phone kinda sounds like a pain (waiting for apps etc)

So the thing about Chromecast is that it relies on the apps to work. Unlike Apple TV, which works with anything on your iPhone (to varying degrees), Chromecast relies entirely on the app's ability to ship a link or content over to the 'cast.

This is both good and bad: it means apps like NetFlix can display content on the Chromecast, regardless of the platform. The bad is that many apps aren't going to get support at all, and for competitors like Amazon Instant Video, we can probably never expect comprehensive support.
 
Upvote
-1 (10 / -11)

tedwick

Wise, Aged Ars Veteran
136
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=29841049#p29841049:37eiicqx said:
DrDenim[/url]":37eiicqx]I only remember reading inital reviews of the chromecast saying it was pretty garbage. Laggy, lacking features and pretty useless. Did it ever get better? Does it work with my wife's iphone? Having to navigate with my phone kinda sounds like a pain (waiting for apps etc)

Reviews from who? Think Chromecast is probably the most used gadget in my house. Navigating via phone is kinda meh, but it beats the hell out of navigating using a remote a la Apple TV/Xbox/Roku/etc. However, easiest way to drive it is via a computer. I usually find content on my laptop while in the living room (Netflix, Youtube, Google Music) and cast from there. Far easier than using a phone.

WRT the iPhone... it's platform agnostic via SOAP, so if the apps she uses are Chromecast enabled, they should work. I know it works from the Netflix app on iOS at least.
 
Upvote
22 (25 / -3)
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=29841049#p29841049:1uil24ck said:
DrDenim[/url]":1uil24ck]I only remember reading inital reviews of the chromecast saying it was pretty garbage. Laggy, lacking features and pretty useless. Did it ever get better? Does it work with my wife's iphone? Having to navigate with my phone kinda sounds like a pain (waiting for apps etc)

Our friends never have a problem using it with their iPhones when they come over. The only time it ever lags for us is when we try to cast from the Google Photos site (which is disappointing). Early reviews were positive, so I'm not sure what you were reading.
 
Upvote
17 (17 / 0)

DrDenim

Ars Scholae Palatinae
617
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=29841117#p29841117:30ep3o7e said:
TomXP411[/url]":30ep3o7e]
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=29841049#p29841049:30ep3o7e said:
DrDenim[/url]":30ep3o7e]I only remember reading inital reviews of the chromecast saying it was pretty garbage. Laggy, lacking features and pretty useless. Did it ever get better? Does it work with my wife's iphone? Having to navigate with my phone kinda sounds like a pain (waiting for apps etc)

So the thing about Chromecast is that it relies on the apps to work. Unlike Apple TV, which works with anything on your iPhone (to varying degrees), Chromecast relies entirely on the app's ability to ship a link or content over to the 'cast.

This is both good and bad: it means apps like NetFlix can display content on the Chromecast, regardless of the platform. The bad is that many apps aren't going to get support at all, and for competitors like Amazon Instant Video, we can probably never expect comprehensive support.

Right. No amazon VOD is lame, maybe a deal breaker. With netflix and amazonVOD we can cut cable. But especially now that netflix remove more and more stuff amazon is necessary (even though the app is garbage)
 
Upvote
5 (5 / 0)
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=29841091#p29841091:jg87igrb said:
Ars of Ares[/url]":jg87igrb]
The moment you open the Netflix app, Netflix detects you have a Chromecast and pre-loads the app on the TV

I hope this doesn't mean the Chromecast switches inputs automatically. We had a problem with that on my wife's Kindle. I'd be playing PS3 or whatever, and she'd fire up Netflix on her Kindle - and it would engage the Chromecast, which would switch inputs on the TV. It got annoying very quickly.

That should be controllable through the TV. At least I can turn it off on my Phillips.
 
Upvote
9 (9 / 0)

DrDenim

Ars Scholae Palatinae
617
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=29841125#p29841125:yiiquknr said:
tedwick[/url]":yiiquknr]
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=29841049#p29841049:yiiquknr said:
DrDenim[/url]":yiiquknr]I only remember reading inital reviews of the chromecast saying it was pretty garbage. Laggy, lacking features and pretty useless. Did it ever get better? Does it work with my wife's iphone? Having to navigate with my phone kinda sounds like a pain (waiting for apps etc)

Reviews from who? Think Chromecast is probably the most used gadget in my house. Navigating via phone is kinda meh, but it beats the hell out of navigating using a remote a la Apple TV/Xbox/Roku/etc. However, easiest way to drive it is via a computer. I usually find content on my laptop while in the living room (Netflix, Youtube, Google Music) and cast from there. Far easier than using a phone.

WRT the iPhone... it's platform agnostic via SOAP, so if the apps she uses are Chromecast enabled, they should work. I know it works from the Netflix app on iOS at least.

I guess I like that I can navigate, and wait on, netflix on the PS3 in the background while using my phone at the same time. Having to wait for the netflix app to load etc on my slow-ass phone means I'm using two screens to watch one..
 
Upvote
-8 (2 / -10)

lewax00

Ars Legatus Legionis
17,402
I only remember reading inital reviews of the chromecast saying it was pretty garbage. Laggy, lacking features and pretty useless. Did it ever get better? Does it work with my wife's iphone? Having to navigate with my phone kinda sounds like a pain (waiting for apps etc)
It depends on your use case. It's laggy when casting interactive things (like casting your desktop, web pages you're trying to demo, etc.). It's great for video on web pages (the video will be little behind your computer if you're casting it as a tab, but it will run smoothly, i.e. it's a latency issue, not a bandwidth one) and pretty much perfect for video from apps that hook in directly (like Netflix, Plex, and HBO Go). I believe in-app support is possible from the iPhone. And I find navigating with my phone to be a much better interface than navigating with a remote.

All in all, I have 2 Chromecasts and an Android TV (Nvidia Shield) that supports casting. Since the second one has been supplanted by the Android TV, I leave it attached to an extra monitor that has HDMI audio support and plop it down when I want to watch something where there isn't a screen (like the kitchen while cooking). They're great little devices, IMO.
 
Upvote
4 (4 / 0)
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=29841173#p29841173:2jflu5ls said:
Terabitman[/url]":2jflu5ls]
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=29841091#p29841091:2jflu5ls said:
Ars of Ares[/url]":2jflu5ls]
The moment you open the Netflix app, Netflix detects you have a Chromecast and pre-loads the app on the TV

I hope this doesn't mean the Chromecast switches inputs automatically. We had a problem with that on my wife's Kindle. I'd be playing PS3 or whatever, and she'd fire up Netflix on her Kindle - and it would engage the Chromecast, which would switch inputs on the TV. It got annoying very quickly.

That should be controllable through the TV. At least I can turn it off on my Phillips.

That's just it: I want Chromecast to switch inputs - when I want to cast. I just don't want it to switch inputs when I want to watch something on my phone or tablet. Adjusting the settings on the TV would block both.

The behavior stopped on the Kindle Netflix app, so maybe they have it figured out. Hopefully.
 
Upvote
4 (4 / 0)

test6554

Ars Scholae Palatinae
1,156
Uggghh. I literally just bought thousands of dollars worth of Sonos "connect" gear last month to control my existing speakers around the house. Before I jumped in, I asked around if there was a chromecast for audio. Nobody had heard of such a magical device.

As for chromecast, it's central to my whole media setup. I cast my plex media server via chromecast. Now that I have it near my router the quality is much better. Granted I also have Amazon Fire TV which works with plex and sling.tv and is equally awesome.
 
Upvote
4 (6 / -2)
[url=http://arstechnica.co.uk/civis/viewtopic.php?p=29841091#p29841091:2uititf6 said:
Ars of Ares[/url]":2uititf6]
The moment you open the Netflix app, Netflix detects you have a Chromecast and pre-loads the app on the TV

I hope this doesn't mean the Chromecast switches inputs automatically. We had a problem with that on my wife's Kindle. I'd be playing PS3 or whatever, and she'd fire up Netflix on her Kindle - and it would engage the Chromecast, which would switch inputs on the TV. It got annoying very quickly.

There's a simple solution for that - get a new wife.
 
Upvote
3 (13 / -10)

Spuzzell

Ars Scholae Palatinae
1,327
Controlling a Chromecast from an Android tablet is pretty much foolproof, if it's an issue with your iDevice just buy a cheap tablet as a dedicated controller. (I know, iSacrilege)

However, I only use the Chromecast a couple of times a month for casting BT Sport, Eurosport and ESPN to a projector when I want to watch a sporting occasion on a huge screen.

Pretty much everything else (Amazon, Netflix, Plex) just run natively on my smart TVs without the need for any other hardware.

I like the Chromecast and for £20 it's worth picking one up for travel or occasional use as in my case, but the usage scenario for these is getting narrower with every new generation of TV.

It's not going to be long before the majority of people have TVs that do what Chromecast/Apple TV on their own.

(also, I'm pretty sure the existing Chromecast is more than happy handling 1080p)
 
Upvote
1 (5 / -4)

DrDenim

Ars Scholae Palatinae
617
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=29841259#p29841259:2tmri3y8 said:
test6554[/url]":2tmri3y8]Uggghh. I literally just bought thousands of dollars worth of Sonos gear last month and asked around if there was a chromecast for audio. Nobody had heard of such a magical device.

Lol, I bought two sonos' last year too. But considering how janky and drop-support-in-a-year google stuff is I think I'm glad I went with Sonos.
 
Upvote
-7 (5 / -12)
Do I need to buy a new Chromecast to get Spotify support?

Update: No Spotify updates available. And no update pushed out to my Chromecast yet.

Update: According to The Verge, Spotify support will roll out to the original device within a few weeks. Great! It's the biggest issue I have with it atm.
www.theverge.com/2015/9/29/9409673/goog ... fy-support
 
Upvote
0 (0 / 0)

DrDenim

Ars Scholae Palatinae
617
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=29841293#p29841293:4gc6plha said:
Spuzzell[/url]":4gc6plha]Controlling a Chromecast from an Android tablet is pretty much foolproof, if it's an issue with your iDevice just buy a cheap tablet as a dedicated controller. (I know, iSacrilege)

However, I only use the Chromecast a couple of times a month for casting BT Sport, Eurosport and ESPN to a projector when I want to watch a sporting occasion on a huge screen.

Pretty much everything else (Amazon, Netflix, Plex) just run natively on my smart TVs without the need for any other hardware.

I like the Chromecast and for £20 it's worth picking one up for travel or occasional use as in my case, but the usage scenario for these is getting narrower with every new generation of TV.

It's not going to be long before the majority of people have TVs that do what Chromecast/Apple TV on their own.

(also, I'm pretty sure the existing Chromecast is more than happy handling 1080p)

Used my MIL's samsung smart TV. Yeah no thanks.

And my TV is only 5 years old. Hope to keep it another 5-10. It's way cheaper to buy a $35 or $99 device than a new TV when my plasma still looks great.
 
Upvote
15 (15 / 0)

stjns

Ars Centurion
338
Subscriptor
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=29841297#p29841297:kl63icdm said:
DrDenim[/url]":kl63icdm]
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=29841259#p29841259:kl63icdm said:
test6554[/url]":kl63icdm]Uggghh. I literally just bought thousands of dollars worth of Sonos gear last month and asked around if there was a chromecast for audio. Nobody had heard of such a magical device.

Lol, I bought two sonos' last year too. But considering how janky and drop-support-in-a-year google stuff is I think I'm glad I went with Sonos.

Yeah, that hasn't been the case with the Chromecast. Like the article said, the device itself is two years old and still works great. Some Google stuff is janky, for sure (looking at you, Nexus Player), but the Chromecast is awesome.

As much as I'm tempted to buy the new one, I really have no reason to; the current gen still works great for casting Google Play Music, Pandora, and Netflix, which is pretty much my entire usecase. I am sure to buy a few of the Audio versions once the synchronization update is released, however. It's about time someone gave Sonos a proper run for their money. I hope this device can do it.
 
Upvote
10 (10 / 0)

Spuzzell

Ars Scholae Palatinae
1,327
[url=http://arstechnica.co.uk/civis/viewtopic.php?p=29841341#p29841341:cnjyb3am said:
DrDenim[/url]":cnjyb3am]
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=29841293#p29841293:cnjyb3am said:
Spuzzell[/url]":cnjyb3am]Controlling a Chromecast from an Android tablet is pretty much foolproof, if it's an issue with your iDevice just buy a cheap tablet as a dedicated controller. (I know, iSacrilege)

However, I only use the Chromecast a couple of times a month for casting BT Sport, Eurosport and ESPN to a projector when I want to watch a sporting occasion on a huge screen.

Pretty much everything else (Amazon, Netflix, Plex) just run natively on my smart TVs without the need for any other hardware.

I like the Chromecast and for £20 it's worth picking one up for travel or occasional use as in my case, but the usage scenario for these is getting narrower with every new generation of TV.

It's not going to be long before the majority of people have TVs that do what Chromecast/Apple TV on their own.

(also, I'm pretty sure the existing Chromecast is more than happy handling 1080p)

Used my MIL's samsung smart TV. Yeah no thanks.

And my TV is only 5 years old. Hope to keep it another 5-10. It's way cheaper to buy a $35 or $99 device than a new TV when my plasma still looks great.

Well, I freaking LOVE my Samsung. The remote is both voice activated and has gesture controls with an onscreen mouse cursor, and the TV itself is a quadcore speed demon.

My Sony is less user friendly but is a 2013 model.

I absolutely understand where you're coming from but as I say, the number of people in your situation who need these devices is decreasing rapidly every day.
 
Upvote
-1 (0 / -1)

stjns

Ars Centurion
338
Subscriptor
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=29841389#p29841389:95pkt6pq said:
filburt[/url]":95pkt6pq]It's probably a cost issue, but I think Google should've figured out a way to make them a single device. $35 for ChromeCast 2 (video) is a bargain but $35 for ChromeCast Audio seems like a rip off in comparison (even though it may not be).

I guess it's a relativity thing. It seems strange that it's the same price, but when compared to other products with similar capabilities, it seems like an incredible bargain to me.
 
Upvote
7 (7 / 0)

Spuzzell

Ars Scholae Palatinae
1,327
[url=http://arstechnica.co.uk/civis/viewtopic.php?p=29841403#p29841403:1ckt1dm6 said:
WagonWheelsRX8[/url]":1ckt1dm6]I'm still confused why Chromecast is so popular but similar (and more useful) devices like the Miracast dongles are almost unknown.
I guess they are slightly pricier ($50 vs $35) but they don't have the same limitations, either.

Again, might be that so many TVs support Miracast natively.
 
Upvote
0 (1 / -1)

TomXP411

Ars Tribunus Angusticlavius
9,356
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=29841189#p29841189:3iblzbg0 said:
Ars of Ares[/url]":3iblzbg0]You can cast your screen for Amazon VOD, but it doesn't look great. It's really lame that Amazon only recently put their app on Android; I don't expect Amazon to support Chromecast any time soon (despite vocal desire for it).

The last time I looked, Instant Video didn't even support HDMI out - it just mirrored the iPad's screen, 4:3 and all.

I think Amazon is really focused on supporting their own stuff first and everyone else second. It's kind of frustrating, since Amazon video is supported on a lot more devices, including all the game consoles and computers... but it's somewhat crippled on most of those devices, thanks to not being able to buy content on the apps.
 
Upvote
3 (3 / 0)

DrDenim

Ars Scholae Palatinae
617
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=29841367#p29841367:1sieh0ox said:
Bodacious[/url]":1sieh0ox]
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=29841297#p29841297:1sieh0ox said:
DrDenim[/url]":1sieh0ox]
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=29841259#p29841259:1sieh0ox said:
test6554[/url]":1sieh0ox]Uggghh. I literally just bought thousands of dollars worth of Sonos gear last month and asked around if there was a chromecast for audio. Nobody had heard of such a magical device.

Lol, I bought two sonos' last year too. But considering how janky and drop-support-in-a-year google stuff is I think I'm glad I went with Sonos.

Yeah, that hasn't been the case with the Chromecast. Like the article said, the device itself is two years old and still works great. Some Google stuff is janky, for sure (Nexus Player), but the Chromecast is awesome.

My comment was as much about Android as Chromecast. I kinda hate android. It's often buggy and unfinished. I just hate iOS more.

With no amazon VOD support unfortunate I think I'll have to wait for Roku 4. Bad enough looking for shows across 3-4 services, so don't want to have to use several devices as well. "Is this show on netflix or hulu or amazon? Which of the 3 inputs is that on again??" ugh what a nightmare
#firstworldproblmes..
 
Upvote
-1 (5 / -6)
[url=http://meincmagazine.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=29841429#p29841429:2ps7vigk said:
Spuzzell[/url]":2ps7vigk]
[url=http://arstechnica.co.uk/civis/viewtopic.php?p=29841403#p29841403:2ps7vigk said:
WagonWheelsRX8[/url]":2ps7vigk]I'm still confused why Chromecast is so popular but similar (and more useful) devices like the Miracast dongles are almost unknown.
I guess they are slightly pricier ($50 vs $35) but they don't have the same limitations, either.

Again, might be that so many TVs support Miracast natively.

I never got into the Miracast thing because I didn't want to mirror my device. With Chromecast, you don't have to. Though it will mirror your device, if you want, which kind of negates the 'more useful' argument favoring Miracast. Granted, Chromecast didn't always support screen mirroring.
 
Upvote
11 (12 / -1)
Status
Not open for further replies.