So long, Assistant—Gemini is taking over Google Maps

Post content hidden for low score. Show…

MrRtd

Ars Centurion
296
Subscriptor
While Google has recently been forced to acknowledge that hallucinations are inevitable, the Maps team says it does not expect that to be a problem with this version of Gemini. The suggestions coming from the generative AI bot are grounded in Google’s billions of place listings and Street View photos. This will, allegedly, make the robot less likely to make up a location. Google also says in no uncertain terms that Gemini is not responsible for choosing your route.
So it chooses your route, but simultaneously also not responsible. Doesn't convey a sense of confidence.
 
Upvote
105 (121 / -16)

Sarty

Ars Tribunus Angusticlavius
7,998
The robot will, however, get involved with the spoken directions. Currently, Google Maps and other navigation systems use vague instructions like “turn in 500 feet.” However, these announcements often arrive far too late to be useful, and can people accurately gauge 500 feet while driving? The Gemini-based solution is to give instructions with landmarks.
Uh, I know damned good and well how far 500 feet is. In contrast, I do not know what landmark the slopbot thinks is useful or how it will describe it.

Literally, this is why humanity invented standardized units.
 
Upvote
140 (159 / -19)
Post content hidden for low score. Show…

gnesterenko

Wise, Aged Ars Veteran
118
So it chooses your route, but simultaneously also not responsible. Doesn't convey a sense of confidence.
JFC... it means Gemini only handles the extra stuff like finding restaurants or gas stations or whatnot. Not the mapping & routing function, which gains nothing from leveraging ML.
 
Upvote
70 (70 / 0)

gnesterenko

Wise, Aged Ars Veteran
118
Upvote
24 (25 / -1)

mrkite77

Ars Tribunus Militum
1,797
Have all the good programmers fled Google? The quality of their software has really taken a tumble. Maps is especially bad. For example, open up maps on android.. that microphone button in the top right corner of the search bar doesn't actually work.. like it's not a button. You have to tap on the search bar itself, which opens up a new interface with a different microphone button that does work.
 
Upvote
0 (10 / -10)

True Neutral

Ars Centurion
337
Subscriptor++
A work buddy of mine and me tried a little experiment with Gemini... We both on our phones would ask the exact same question about certain things and we made sure to spell and punctuate the same way.

Gemini would sometimes give starkly different answers to the same question, responding in the affirmative on one phone and in the negative on the other phone.

So, needless to say, we don't really trust Gemini to be consistent.
 
Upvote
52 (52 / 0)

DrewW

Ars Tribunus Militum
2,064
Subscriptor++
Upvote
7 (9 / -2)

SixDegrees

Ars Legatus Legionis
48,651
Subscriptor
Have all the good programmers fled Google? The quality of their software has really taken a tumble. Maps is especially bad. For example, open up maps on android.. that microphone button in the top right corner of the search bar doesn't actually work.. like it's not a button. You have to tap on the search bar itself, which opens up a new interface with a different microphone button that does work.
All the good programmers have retired. Their successors don't write code anymore; they let AI write code for them that never gets properly tested, just immediately deployed. UIs, for example, are definitely NOT a solved problem, but there hasn't been any innovation at all in the space for many years.
 
Upvote
35 (37 / -2)

Epyon9283

Ars Scholae Palatinae
774
Subscriptor++
Have all the good programmers fled Google? The quality of their software has really taken a tumble. Maps is especially bad. For example, open up maps on android.. that microphone button in the top right corner of the search bar doesn't actually work.. like it's not a button. You have to tap on the search bar itself, which opens up a new interface with a different microphone button that does work.
The microphone button works for me. Single tap of the icon and I get the "Say where you want to go" prompt.
 
Upvote
7 (7 / 0)

mrkite77

Ars Tribunus Militum
1,797
The microphone button works for me. Single tap of the icon and I get the "Say where you want to go" prompt.
It doesn't for me on a pixel 9a. This button:

Screenshot_20251105-080017.png
 
Upvote
5 (5 / 0)

Freebeau

Wise, Aged Ars Veteran
112
Subscriptor
Glad I don't use Google Maps.
Please tell me what you use for maps. I have been getting more and more dissatisfied with Google Maps even before Gemini. It just acts so strange compared to a few years ago. I ask for lodging in a certain small town and I get about a quarter of the USA instead.
 
Upvote
19 (19 / 0)

facw

Ars Scholae Palatinae
644
Instead of only using distances for turns, Gemini might use a gas station, restaurant, or recognizable sign to help you find your turn

I noticed yesterday that Android Auto's Google Maps had just added a bunch of map markers (in blinding white on night mode) for crappy chain restaurants. I had assumed they were just hoping to sell ads for that sort of thing, but I guess they also want to fold those into directions for even more brand awareness potential (I don't buy landmark navigation being easier at all)
 
Upvote
14 (14 / 0)
So it chooses your route, but simultaneously also not responsible. Doesn't convey a sense of confidence.
I took this as, Gemini isn't doing the actual navigating to the location, rather, it's used when you ask questions about additional locations, then passes that information to the program creating the route - not that Google is saying Gemini isn't responsible for hallucinations... Am I incorrect?
 
Upvote
7 (7 / 0)

NomadUK

Ars Scholae Palatinae
810
Subscriptor++
Please tell me what you use for maps. I have been getting more and more dissatisfied with Google Maps even before Gemini. It just acts so strange compared to a few years ago. I ask for lodging in a certain small town and I get about a quarter of the USA instead.
I use Apple Maps. If they wind up putting adverts in, as some reports indicate they may, I'll move to something else, such as OpenMaps, or CoMaps, or something.
 
Upvote
3 (4 / -1)